Should Controls With Respiratory Symptoms Be Excluded From Case-Control Studies of Pneumonia Etiology? Reflections From the PERCH Study

Higdon, Melissa M.; Hammitt, Laura L.; Deloria Knoll, Maria; Baggett, Henry C.; Brooks, W. Abdullah; Howie, Stephen R. C.; Kotloff, Karen L.; Levine, Orin S.; Madhi, Shabir A.; Murdoch, David R.; Scott, J. Anthony G.; Thea, Donald M.; Driscoll, Amanda J.; Karron, Ruth A.; Park, Daniel E.; Prosperi, Christine; Zeger, Scott L.; O’Brien, Katherine L.; Feikin, Daniel R.

Back to Previous Page

Should Controls With Respiratory Symptoms Be Excluded From Case-Control Studies of Pneumonia Etiology? Reflections From the PERCH Study

Published Date:

Jun 15 2017

Source:

Clin Infect Dis. 2017; 64(Suppl 3):S205-S212.

[PDF-525.24 KB]

Details:

Alternative Title:

Clin Infect Dis

Personal Author:

Higdon, Melissa M. ; Hammitt, Laura L. ; Deloria Knoll, Maria ; Baggett, Henry C. ; Brooks, W. Abdullah ; ... More ▼

Corporate Authors:

for the PERCH Study Group O’BrienKatherine L.LevineOrin S.KnollMaria DeloriaFeikinDaniel R.DeLucaAndrea N.DriscollAmanda J.FuWeiHammittLaura L.HigdonMelissa M.KaguciaE. WangeciKarronRuth A.LiMengyingParkDaniel E.ProsperiChristineWuZhenkeZegerScott L.WatsonNora L.CrawleyJaneMurdochDavid R.BrooksW. AbdullahEndtzHubert P.ZamanKhalequGoswamiDoliHossainLokmanJahanYasminAshrafHasanHowieStephen R. C.EbrukeBernard E.AntonioMartinMcLellanJessicaMachukaEuniceShamsulArifinZamanSyed M.A.MackenzieGrantScottJ. Anthony G.AworiJuliet O.MorpethSusan C.KamauAliceKazunguSidiKotloffKaren L.TapiaMilagritos D.SowSamba O.SyllaMamadouTambouraBoubouOnwuchekwaUmaKouroumaNanaToureAliouMadhiShabir A.MooreDavid P.AdrianPeter V.BaillieVicky L.KuwandaLocadiahMudauAzwifarwiGroomeMichelle J.BaggettHenry C.ThamthitiwatSomsakMaloneySusan A.BunthiCharatdaoRhodesJuliaSawatwongPongpunAkarasewiPasakornTheaDonald M.MwananyandaLawrenceChipetaJamesSeidenbergPhilMwansaJameswa SomweSomweKwendaGeoffrey

Description:

Many pneumonia etiology case-control studies exclude controls with respiratory illness from enrollment or analyses. Herein we argue that selecting controls regardless of respiratory symptoms provides the least biased estimates of pneumonia etiology. We review 3 reasons investigators may choose to exclude controls with respiratory symptoms in light of epidemiologic principles of control selection and present data from the Pneumonia Etiology Research for Child Health (PERCH) study where relevant to assess their validity. We conclude that exclusion of controls with respiratory symptoms will result in biased estimates of etiology. Randomly selected community controls, with or without respiratory symptoms, as long as they do not meet the criteria for case-defining pneumonia, are most representative of the general population from which cases arose and the least subject to selection bias.

Subject:

[+]

Pubmed ID:

28575354

Pubmed Central ID:

PMC5447853

Document Type:

Journal Article

Collection(s):

CDC Public Access

Main Document Checksum:

[+]

File Type:

Supporting Files:

	cix076.nxml	application/octet-stream
	cix07601.gif	image/gif
	cix07601.jpg	image/jpeg
	cix07602.gif	image/gif
	cix07602.jpg	image/jpeg
	cix07603.gif	image/gif
	cix07603.jpg	image/jpeg

No Related Documents.

Standardization of Laboratory Methods for the PERCH Study

[PDF - 391.52 KB]

Personal Author:

Driscoll, Amanda J. ; Karron, Ruth A. ; ...

Published Date:

Jun 15 2017

Source:

Clin Infect Dis. 2017; 64(Suppl 3):S245-S252.

Description:

The Pneumonia Etiology Research for Child Health study was conducted across 7 diverse research sites and relied on standardized clinical and laborator...

File Type:

[PDF - 391.52 KB]

File Type:

[PDF - 391.52 KB]
Is Higher Viral Load in the Upper Respiratory Tract Associated With Severe Pneumonia? Findings From the PERCH Study

[PDF - 1.13 MB]

Personal Author:

Feikin, Daniel R. ; Fu, Wei ; ...

Corporate Authors:

for the PERCH Study Group O’BrienKatherine L.LevineOrin S.KnollMaria DeloriaFeikinDaniel R.DeLucaAndrea N.DriscollAmanda J.FancourtNicholasFuWeiHammittLaura L.HigdonMelissa M.KaguciaE. WangeciKarronRuth A.LiMengyingParkDaniel E.ProsperiChristineWuZhenkeZegerScott L.WatsonNora L.CrawleyJaneMurdochDavid R.BrooksW. AbdullahEndtzHubert P.ZamanKhalequGoswamiDoliHossainLokmanJahanYasminAshrafHasanHowieStephen R. C.EbrukeBernard E.AntonioMartinMcLellanJessicaMachukaEuniceShamsulArifinZamanSyed M.A.MackenzieGrantScottJ. Anthony G.AworiJuliet O.MorpethSusan C.KamauAliceKazunguSidiOmindeMicah SilabaKotloffKaren L.TapiaMilagritos D.SowSamba O.SyllaMamadouTambouraBoubouOnwuchekwaUmaKouroumaNanaToureAliouMadhiShabir A.MooreDavid P.AdrianPeter V.BaillieVicky L.KuwandaLocadiahMudauAzwifarwiGroomeMichelle J.MahomedNasreenBaggettHenry C.ThamthitiwatSomsakMaloneySusan A.BunthiCharatdaoRhodesJuliaSawatwongPongpunAkarasewiPasakornTheaDonald M.MwananyandaLawrenceChipetaJamesSeidenbergPhilMwansaJameswa SomweSomweKwendaGeoffreyAndersonTrevor P.MitchellJoanne

Published Date:

Jun 15 2017

Source:

Clin Infect Dis. 2017; 64(Suppl 3):S337-S346.

Description:

Background.The etiologic inference of identifying a pathogen in the upper respiratory tract (URT) of children with pneumonia is unclear. To determine ...

File Type:

[PDF - 1.13 MB]

File Type:

[PDF - 1.13 MB]
Introduction to the Epidemiologic Considerations, Analytic Methods, and Foundational Results From the Pneumonia Etiology Research for Child Health Study

[PDF - 1.30 MB]

Personal Author:

O’Brien, Katherine L. ; Baggett, Henry C. ; ...

Published Date:

June 15 2017

Source:

Clin Infect Dis. 2017; 64(Suppl 3):S179-S184

File Type:

[PDF - 1.30 MB]

File Type:

[PDF - 1.30 MB]
Investigation of nonresponse bias : Hispanic health and nutrition examination survey

[PDF - 4.87 MB]

Personal Author:

Rowland, Michael, 1945- ; Forthofer, Ron N., 1944- ;

Corporate Authors:

National Center for Health Statistics (U.S.). Division of Health Examination Statistics.

Published Date:

December 1993

Series:

Vital and health statistics. no. 119 Series 2 Data evaluation and methods research
DHHS publication ; no. (PHS) 94-1393

Description:

"This report presents an investigation of potential nonresponse bias in the Hispanic Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (HHANES) conducted during...

File Type:

[PDF - 4.87 MB]

File Type:

[PDF - 4.87 MB]
Safety of Induced Sputum Collection in Children Hospitalized With Severe or Very Severe Pneumonia

[PDF - 147.48 KB]

Personal Author:

DeLuca, Andrea N. ; Hammitt, Laura L. ; ...

Corporate Authors:

for the PERCH Study Group O’BrienKatherine L.LevineOrin S.KnollMaria DeloriaFeikinDaniel R.DeLucaAndrea N.DriscollAmanda J.FancourtNicholasFuWeiHammittLaura L.HigdonMelissa M.KaguciaE. WangeciKarronRuth A.LiMengyingParkDaniel E.ProsperiChristineWuZhenkeZegerScott L.WatsonNora L.CrawleyJaneMurdochDavid R.BrooksW. AbdullahEndtzHubert P.ZamanKhalequGoswamiDoliHossainLokmanJahanYasminAshrafHasanHowieStephen R. C.EbrukeBernard E.AntonioMartinMcLellanJessicaMachukaEuniceShamsulArifinZamanSyed M.A.MackenzieGrantScottJ. Anthony G.AworiJuliet O.MorpethSusan C.KamauAliceKazunguSidiSilabaMicahKotloffKaren L.TapiaMilagritos D.SowSamba O.SyllaMamadouTambouraBoubouOnwuchekwaUmaKouroumaNanaToureAliouMadhiShabir A.MooreDavid P.AdrianPeter V.BaillieVicky L.KuwandaLocadiahMudauAzwifarwiGroomeMichelle J.MahomedNasreenBaggettHenry C.ThamthitiwatSomsakMaloneySusan A.BunthiCharatdaoRhodesJuliaSawatwongPongpunAkarasewiPasakornTheaDonald M.MwananyandaLawrenceChipetaJamesSeidenbergPhilMwansaJameswa SomweSomweKwendaGeoffrey

Published Date:

Jun 15 2017

Source:

Clin Infect Dis. 2017; 64(Suppl 3):S301-S308

Description:

Background.Induced sputum (IS) may provide diagnostic information about the etiology of pneumonia. The safety of this procedure across a heterogeneous...

File Type:

[PDF - 147.48 KB]

File Type:

[PDF - 147.48 KB]

Should Controls With Respiratory Symptoms Be Excluded From Case-Control Studies of Pneumonia Etiology? Reflections From the PERCH Study

Should Controls With Respiratory Symptoms Be Excluded From Case-Control Studies of Pneumonia Etiology? Reflections From the PERCH Study

You May Also Like:

Have Questions?

CDC INFORMATION

CONNECT WITH CDC