Details:

Alternative Title:
Malar J
Personal Author:
Masanja, Irene M. ; McMorrow, Meredith L. ; Maganga, Mussa B. ; Sumari, Debora ; Udhayakumar, Venkatachalam ; ... More +
Masanja, Irene M. ; McMorrow, Meredith L. ; Maganga, Mussa B. ; Sumari, Debora ; Udhayakumar, Venkatachalam ; McElroy, Peter D. ; Kachur, S. Patrick ; Lucchi, Naomi W. Less -
Description:
Background

The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends parasitologic confirmation of suspected malaria cases before treatment. Due to the limited availability of quality microscopy services, this recommendation has become scalable following increased use of antigen-detecting malaria rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) in many malaria-endemic countries. This study was carried out to monitor quality of RDT performance in selected health facilities using two quality assurance (QA) methods: reference microscopy and detection of parasite DNA by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) on dried blood spots (DBS).

Methods

Blood samples for QA were collected from patients undergoing RDT for diagnostic confirmation of malaria during two to three consecutive days per month in 12 health facilities in rural Tanzania. Stained blood smears (BS) were first examined at the district hospitals (BS1) and then at a reference laboratory (BS2). Discordant BS1 and BS2 results prompted a third examination. Molecular analysis was carried out at the Ifakara Health Institute laboratory in Bagamoyo.

Results

Malaria RDTs had a higher positivity rate (6.5%) than qPCR (4.2%) or microscopy (2.9% for BS1 and 2.5% for BS2). Poor correlation was observed between RDT and BS results: BS1 (K = 0.5), BS2 (K = 0.43) and qPCR (K = 0.45), challenging the utility of these tests for RDT QA. In addition, many challenges related to qPCR processing were recorded and long delays in obtaining QA test results for both microscopy and qPCR.

Conclusions

Overall there was limited agreement among the three diagnostic approaches and neither microscopy nor qPCR appear to be good QA options for RDTs under field conditions.


Subjects:
[+]
Diagnostic Tests, Routine/methods Diagnostic Tests, Routine/standards Malaria/diagnosis Microscopy Patient Care Quality Control Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction
Source:
Malar J. 14.
Document Type:
Journal Article
Place as Subject:
Tanzania
Collection(s):
CDC Public Access
Main Document Checksum:
[+]
urn:sha256:6d3de7aeca6b4211c34b267d3854bfd39a6486015258d77797d63abe8e4bd7fb
Download URL:
https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/27939/cdc_27939_DS1.pdf
File Type:

Supporting Files

• 	12936_2015_Article_597.nxml	txt
  	license.txt	txt

More +