Susceptibility to infection varies by species, and asymptomatic birds could be carriers.
In January 2014, an outbreak of infection with highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) A(H5N8) virus began on a duck farm in South Korea and spread to other poultry farms nearby. During this outbreak, many sick or dead wild birds were found around habitats frequented by migratory birds. To determine the causes of death, we examined 771 wild bird carcasses and identified HPAI A(H5N8) virus in 167. Gross and histologic lesions were observed in pancreas, lung, brain, and kidney of Baikal teals, bean geese, and whooper swans but not mallard ducks. Such lesions are consistent with lethal HPAI A(H5N8) virus infection. However, some HPAI-positive birds had died of gunshot wounds, peritonitis, or agrochemical poisoning rather than virus infection. These findings suggest that susceptibility to HPAI A(H5N8) virus varies among species of migratory birds and that asymptomatic migratory birds could be carriers of this virus.
Highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) A virus infection of gallinaceous birds (e.g., poultry) is associated with high morbidity and mortality rates (
Within the past 10 years, 4 outbreaks of HPAI A(H5N1) have occurred in South Korea (during winter and spring); migratory birds were identified as putative vectors (
During January–June 2014, a total of 771 wild bird carcassess were submitted to the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency in Anyang, South Korea (
| Cause of death | Diagnosis | No. birds* |
|---|---|---|
| Pathogen
(18.5%) | Highly pathogenic avian influenza A virus infection | 167 (29) |
| Bacterial infection | 29 | |
| Parasite infection | 9 (1) | |
| Fungal infection | 3 | |
| Nonpathogen (81.5%) | Agrochemical poisoning | 222 |
| Gunshot | 12 | |
| Trauma | 103 | |
| Miscellaneous | 32 | |
| Putrefaction | 52 | |
| Unknown | 142 |
*Parentheses indicate number of birds in which a pathogenic organism was detected in combination with agrochemical poisoning.
Baikal teal captured at Donglim Reservoir, showing A) neurologic signs of torticollis, ataxia, and limb paresis; B) hemorrhage and necrosis in heart muscle; C) edema and congestion of lung; and D) necrosis of pancreas.
| Family/species | No. birds, n = 167 | Region | Date | Gross lesions | Infected organs | Other cause of death |
| Anatidae | ||||||
| Baikal teal ( | 122 | Donglim Reservoir | Jan 17–22 | Y | T, C, K, L, Lu, P | None |
| 1 | Jeonbuk | Jan 21 | Y | P | None | |
| 5 | Geumgang River | Jan 22, 27 | Y | T, C, K, Lu, P | None | |
| 20 | Chungnam | Jan 23 | Y | T, K, P, H | Monocrotophos poisoning | |
| Bean goose ( | 9 | Donglim Reservoir | Jan 19–21 | N | T (K) | Monocrotophos poisoning ( |
| 1 | Incheon | Feb 1 | Y | UK | None | |
| 1 | Gyeonggi | Mar 9 | Y | T, C, P | None | |
| Mallard ( | 1 | Jeonnam | Jan 27 | N | UK | Peritonitis |
| 1 | Jeonnam | Jan 29 | N | UK | Gunshot, parasite infection | |
| White-fronted goose ( | 1 | Gyeonggi | Jan 28 | N | UK | None |
| Whooper swan ( | 1 | Jeonbuk | Feb 6 | Y | UK | Renal failure |
| Other (not Anatidae) | ||||||
| Coot ( | 1 | Donglim Reservoir | Jan 22 | None | I, K | Postmortem change |
| Little grebe ( | 2 | Gyeonggi | Feb 27 | None | T, C, K | Postmortem change |
| Great egret ( | 1 | Jeonbuk | Mar 8 | N | UK | Peritonitis |
*C, cecal tonsil; H, heart; I, intestine, K, kidney; L, liver; Lu, lung; N, no; T, trachea P, pancreas; UK, unknown (pooled trachea, cecal tonsil, and kidney); Y, yes.
Tissue samples from wild birds were inoculated into specific pathogen free embryonated chicken eggs (9–11 days of gestation), and influenza viruses were identified by using a hemagglutination assay and reverse transcription PCR. Virus identification was confirmed by sequence analysis, as described previously (
Paraffin-embedded sections were cut (5 μm), dewaxed, and stained with hematoxylin and eosin. Duplicate sections were immunohistochemically analyzed to determine the distribution of influenza virus antigens in individual tissues. Briefly, sections were stained with a mouse monoclonal antibody against influenza A virus nucleoprotein (MCA-400; AbD Serotec, Duesseldorf, Germany), followed by a biotinylated goat anti-mouse IgG secondary antibody. Bound antibodies were detected with an avidin-biotin detection system (Ventana Medical Systems, Tucson, AZ, USA). The RedMap kit (Ventana Medical Systems) served as the substrate chromogen.
Of a total of 771 wild birds, HPAI A(H5N8) viruses were isolated from 167. For the other 604 birds, test results for other avian influenza viruses were negative (
During January–March 2014, a total of 167 wild birds of 8 species were infected with HPAI A(H5N8) virus. All 148 infected Baikal teals showed evidence of multifocal necrosis in the pancreas and liver, pulmonary congestion and edema, subepicardial hemorrhage, and myocarditis (
Histologic examination revealed lesions in the pancreas, kidney, brain, and lung of all 8 birds examined. The pancreas showed moderate to severe, multifocal to confluent acinar necrosis, and virus antigen was detected in necrotic cells (
Histopathologic and immunohistochemical (IHC) testing results for Baikal teal. A) Focal necrosis in pancreas (hematoxylin and eosin [H&E] stain). B) Avian influenza virus antigen in necrotic pancreatic acini ([IHC stain). C) Gout and renal tubular necrosis (H&E stain). D) Avian influenza virus antigen in renal tubule cells (IHC stain). Original magnifications ×100.
| Organ | Positive result by histopathology/immunohistochemistry* | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baikal teal, 8/8 | Bean goose, 2/2 | Whooper swan, 1/1 | Mallard, 0/0 | |
| Trachea | –/– | NT | NT | NT |
| Lung | +/+ | +/++ | NT | NT |
| Heart | –/± | +/++ | –/– | –/– |
| Brain | +/++ | +/++ | +/++ | NT |
| Kidney | +/++ | +/++ | ++/++ | NT |
| Skeletal muscle | –/– | NT | NT | NT |
| Intestine | –/– | –/– | –/– | –/– |
| Pancreas | +++/+++ | ++/+++ | ++/++ | –/– |
| Liver | ++/++ | NT | ±/+ | NT |
| Spleen | –/– | –/– | +/– | NT |
| *Histopathologic results: –, no lesions; +, mild lesions; ++, moderate lesions, +++, severe lesions. Immunochemistry results: –, no antigen; ±, faint antigen; +, mild antigen; ++,moderate antigen; +++ severe antigen; NT, not tested. | ||||
In 2 of 3 bean geese examined, major histopathologic lesions were found in the same organs as in the Baikal teals. Moderate multifocal pancreatic necrosis was also observed. Myocardial myofibers showed evidence of segmental necrosis, and mildly swollen nuclei, focal necrosis, and virus antigen were detected in the heart (
Histopathologic and immunohistochemical (IHC) testing results for bean goose. A) Diffuse necrotizing pancreatitis (hematoxylin and eosin [H&E] stain). B) Avian influenza virus antigen in necrotic pancreatic cells (IHC stain). C) Segmental necrosis of myofibers with mildly swollen nuclei focal necrosis (H&E stain). D) Avian influenza virus antigen in necrotic myofiber of the heart (IHC stain). E) Paucity of Purkinje cells, cerebellum (H&E stain). F) Avian influenza virus antigen in Purkinje cells (IHC stain). G) Neuronal necrosis and perivascular cuffing, cerebrum (H&E stain). H) Avian influenza virus antigen in neuron and glial cells (IHC stain). Original magnifications ×100.
In the 1 bird examined, lesions were found mainly in the pancreas, kidney, and brain. The distribution of the lesions and the antigenic staining patterns were similar to those observed for bean geese.
Of the 2 mallard ducks examined, a heterotopic parasite was observed in the pancreas of 1 and fibrinous peritonitis affecting the pancreas and intestine was observed in the other. No virus antigen was detected in the intestine or pancreas of either bird (
The 2014 outbreak of HPAI A(H5N8) in South Korea was unexpected because the H5N8 subtype is uncommon in this area. A genetic characterization study suggests that this H5N8 virus (clade 2.3.4.6) was introduced into South Korea by migratory birds and spread from there to poultry farms (
Infection with H5N8 virus was found in all 148 Baikal teals, 2 bean geese, and 1 whooper swan. Necrotic lesions and avian influenza virus antigen staining were observed in multiple visceral organs, suggesting that the H5N8 virus causes a systemic infection. It also seems that the neurotropism of the H5N8 virus was the key factor contributing to death in these migratory birds of 3 species. The results of this study are consistent with those of other studies of HPAI pathogenicity in experimentally infected waterfowl (
Although a few Baikal teals were sick but not dead, the infection was clinically severe, and gross and histopathologic lesions were found. In addition, in 9 bean geese (all found in the same location at the same time), no evidence of lesions was found; however, the H5N8 virus was identified in the trachea and kidneys. Thus, the H5N8 virus did not cause sudden death in these waterfowl, despite their infection with the virus. This finding suggests that the infection is not peracute during the early stages.
By contrast, although mallard ducks and white-fronted geese were asymptomatically infected with H5N8 HPAI, these birds died of other causes, including gunshot wounds or peritonitis. Experimental infection studies show that some wild ducks, geese, and swans shed H5N1 virus despite being asymptomatic (
The histopathologic findings and the localization of H5N8 virus antigen associated with renal failure and gout in Baikal teals, bean geese, and whooper swans were unusual. Experimental infection studies have shown that although HPAI (H5N1) infects the tubular epithelium in the kidneys of various waterfowl, no evidence of gross or histopathologic lesions has been found in the kidneys (
In summary, we report the pathogenicity of HPAI A(H5N8) virus (clade 2.3.4.6) in various species of waterfowl in South Korea. Baikal teals, bean geese, and whooper swans are susceptible to this virus, which causes high mortality rates; however, infection in mallard ducks is asymptomatic. Although many questions regarding HPAI A(H5N8) virus pathogenesis remain, the results reported herein suggest that susceptibility to HPAI A(H5N8) virus differs among different species of migratory birds. Thus, these birds may be susceptible to or carriers of this infectious virus.
We thank Hyuk-Man Kwon for excellent technical assistance.
This work was supported by a grant from the National Animal Disease Control Project and the Golden Seed Project (213005-04-1-SBA10) of the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs of Korea.
Dr. Kim is a veterinary researcher at the Animal and Plant Quarantine Agency, Anyang, South Korea. Her research interests include the molecular epidemiology and pathology of avian viral disease.