Leading national organizations are increasingly using evidence-based recommendations for Papanicolaou testing. As of 2003, organizations recommended against Papanicolaou testing for women without a cervix following a hysterectomy who do not have a history of high-grade precancerous lesion or cervical cancer and for women older than 65 years with adequate prior screening and who are not at high risk.
A cross-sectional study was conducted using data from the 2010 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS). The NHIS is a nationally representative survey of the civilian non-institutionalized population of the United States that uses a random, stratified, multistage cluster sampling design. Analyses of public use data are considered exempt by the institutional review board (IRB) of the National Cancer Institute; IRB approval and informed consent were obtained in the original study. In 2010, the NHIS included a Cancer Control Supplement, which is the most recently available national data set that includes detailed items on cervical cancer screening and hysterectomy status, including, for the first time, questions to assess date of self-reported hysterectomy. The Cancer Control Supplement, fielded to adults 18 years and older, had a response rate of 60.8%.
We examined sociodemographic characteristics for our study sample by hysterectomy status and age. We then investigated timing of most recent Papanicolaou test (within the past year, 1–3 years ago, >3 years ago) by sociodemographic characteristics and by hysterectomy status. National estimates of Papanicolaou testing overuse were calculated using the population weights from the 2010 NHIS. Women who reported a history of cervical cancer, an abnormal Papanicolaou test result within the past 3 years, or whose last Papanicolaou test was not part of a routine test were excluded from the results used to generate the national estimates. SAS-callable SUDAAN, version 9.2, was used in all analyses to account for the stratification and clustering of data within the complex survey design of the NHIS.
Among women reporting a hysterectomy, 34.1%(95% CI, 31.7%–36.6%) reported a Papanicolau test in the past year (
For more than a decade, the US Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) has recommended that women discontinue Papanicolaou testing if they have received a total hysterectomy and have no history of cervical cancer or if they are older than 65 years and have ongoing and recent normal Papanicolaou test results.
Limitations of this study are the use of self-reported data to obtain information on Papanicolaou testing and the lack of detail on type of hysterectomy received and on whether older women were adequately screened prior to stopping use of the test.
Misuse of Papanicolaou testing continues despite USPSTF recommendations, and health care resources could be spent better elsewhere. Targeted efforts are needed to reduce unnecessary testing among older women and women without a cervix in compliance with clinical recommendations for cervical cancer prevention.
Characteristics of Women by Hysterectomy Status and by Age, National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) (2010)
| Characteristic | Women 30 Years and Older | Women 65 Years | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reporting No | Reporting Hysterectomy | ||||
| No. (% [95% CI]) | Mean, y | ||||
| Age at | Time Since | ||||
| All women | … | … | 41.3 | 20.2 | … |
| Age, y | |||||
| 30–44 | 2748 (38.1 [36.8–39.5]) | 156 (7.3 [6.1–8.7]) | 33.9 | 5.9 | … |
| 45–64 | 2960 (43.7 [42.3–45.0]) | 1049 (49.6 [47.2–52.1]) | 40.0 | 15.7 | … |
| ≥65 | 1508 (18.2 [17.2–19.3]) | 1073 (43.1 [40.7–45.5]) | 44.2 | 29.9 | … |
| Race/ethnicity | |||||
| Non-Hispanic white | 4214 (70.3 [69.0–71.6]) | 1502 (75.1 [73.1–77.1]) | 41.4 | 22.0 | 1848 (81.0 [79.2–82.7]) |
| Non-Hispanic black | 1149 (11.2 [10.3–12.1]) | 439 (13.6 [12.1–15.4]) | 39.7 | 19.0 | 369 (8.9 [7.7–10.2]) |
| Hispanic or Latino | 1346 (12.5 [11.6–13.4]) | 258 (8.0 [6.9–9.4]) | 41.8 | 15.5 | 255 (6.6 [5.7–7.7]) |
| Other | 507 (6.0 [5.3–6.7]) | 79 (3.2 [2.5–4.1]) | 42.7 | 17.1 | 109 (3.5 [2.8–4.4]) |
| Education | |||||
| Less than high school | 1122 (12.2 [11.3–13.2]) | 430 (15.4 [13.7–17.2]) | 40.7 | 24.9 | 611 (20.0 [18.3–21.9]) |
| High school graduate or GED | 1785 (24.5 [23.2–25.7]) | 753 (35.4 [33.1–37.8]) | 41.0 | 21.2 | 853 (33.8 [31.8–35.9]) |
| Some college | 2105 (29.8 [28.6–31.1]) | 703 (31.1 [29.0–33.3]) | 40.4 | 20.2 | 663 (27.1 [25.2–29.1]) |
| College graduate | 2188 (33.5 [31.9–35.1]) | 384 (18.2 [16.2–20.3]) | 43.6 | 18.1 | 440 (19.0 [17.1–21.1]) |
| Missing | 16 | 8 | … | … | 14 |
| Proportion of poverty level, % | |||||
| <200 | 3230 (36.8 [35.3–38.4]) | 1126 (41.8 [39.5–44.2]) | 40.5 | 23.1 | 1418 (47.9 [45.5–50.3]) |
| 200 to <400 | 1465 (21.4 [20.3–22.6]) | 494 (22.8 [21.0–24.8]) | 41.7 | 21.5 | 551 (23.5 [21.4–25.7]) |
| ≥400 | 2519 (41.8 [40.1–43.4]) | 658 (35.3 [32.9–37.8]) | 41.9 | 18.1 | 612 (28.6 [26.3–31.1]) |
| Missing | 2 | … | … | … | … |
| Health care coverage | |||||
| Private only | 2003 (30.2 [28.7–31.7]) | 434 (22.2 [20.1–24.4]) | 39.8 | 14.2 | |
| Public only | 1491 (16.3 [15.3–17.4]) | 695 (25.5 [23.5–27.5]) | 41.5 | 26.3 | 1209 (42.9 [40.5–45.4]) |
| Public and private | 2639 (40.0 [38.5–41.6]) | 955 (44.6 [42.1–47.0]) | 42.6 | 22.2 | 1315 (54.9 [52.4–57.4]) |
| None | 1069 (13.4 [12.4–14.5]) | 189 (7.8 [6.6–9.2]) | 37.1 | 15.8 | |
| Missing | 14 | 5 | … | … | 57 |
| Has a usual source of health care | |||||
| Yes | 6428 (90.2 [89.4–91.0]) | 2161 (95.2 [94.0–96.1]) | 41.5 | 21.0 | 2504 (97.5 [96.8–98.1]) |
| No | 788 (9.8 [9.0–10.6]) | 116 (4.8 [3.9–6.0]) | 37.5 | 19.0 | 76 (2.5 [1.9–3.2]) |
| Missing | 0 | 1 | … | … | 1 |
| Ever heard of HPV | |||||
| Yes | 4141 (75.4 [74.0–76.8]) | 830 (73.1 [70.1–75.9]) | 39.5 | 13.9 | |
| No | 1554 (24.6 [23.2–26.0]) | 371 (26.9 [24.1–29.9]) | 38.3 | 16.1 | |
| Missing | 1521 | 1077 | … | … | … |
| Time since most recent Papanicolaou test, y | |||||
| <1 | 3790 (54.4 [52.9–55.9]) | 724 (34.1 [31.7–36.6]) | 41.6 | 16.0 | 659 (27.2 [24.9–29.6]) |
| 1–3 | 1880 (26.3 [25.1–27.5]) | 494 (21.7 [19.8–23.7]) | 40.2 | 19.7 | 582 (23.2 [21.2–25.3]) |
| >3 | 1490 (19.3 [18.2–20.4]) | 1036 (44.2 [41.8–46.5]) | 41.6 | 25.2 | 1291 (49.6 [47.2–52.1]) |
| Missing | 56 | 24 | … | … | 49 |
| No. of Papanicolaou tests in past 6 y | |||||
| 0 | 782 (9.9 [9.1–10.9]) | 718 (31.1 [28.8–33.5]) | 41.1 | 26.8 | 907 (34.7 [32.4–37.2]) |
| 1 | 681 (9.2 [8.4–10.0]) | 264 (11.5 [10.0–13.2]) | 41.7 | 21.0 | 326 (12.8 [11.4–14.4]) |
| 2 | 660 (9.0 [8.3–9.9]) | 210 (9.0 [7.7–10.5]) | 40.4 | 22.4 | 250 (10.1 [8.7–11.6]) |
| 3 | 808 (11.4 [10.6–12.2]) | 203 (9.9 [8.4–11.7]) | 40.2 | 19.5 | 255 (11.0 [9.5–12.7]) |
| 4 | 513 (6.7 [6.1–7.4]) | 128 (5.6 [4.6–6.7]) | 41.8 | 16.7 | 129 (4.7 [3.8–5.7]) |
| 5 | 535 (8.2 [7.4–9.2]) | 102 (4.8 [3.8–6.1]) | 41.9 | 19.2 | 122 (5.3 [4.2–6.6]) |
| 6 | 3032 (44.4 [42.9–45.9]) | 593 (26.9 [24.9–29.1]) | 41.6 | 15.9 | 504 (21.2 [19.2–23.2]) |
| ≥7 | 93 (1.1 [0.0–1.4]) | ||||
| Missing | 112 | 60 | … | … | 88 |
Abbreviations: GED, General Education Development; HPV, human papillomavirus.
Includes all women 30 years and older, excluding women who report history of cervical cancer or an abnormal Papanicolaou test result in the past 3 years and women whose last Papanicolaou test was not a routine test (meaning that women who never had a Papanicolaou test are excluded). Mean age at hysterectomy and mean time since hysterectomy are missing for 105 of the 2278 women who report a hysterectomy. Percentages are weighted estimates. Missing responses are not included in the denominator. All analyses account for the stratification and clustering of data within the complex survey design of the NHIS.
Private insurance includes military insurance; public insurance includes Medicaid, Medicare, State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP), Indian Health Service (IHS), and other public and other government insurance types; single service plan is considered underinsured and is included with uninsured.
Suppressed because of count less than 50 and/or relative standard error greater than 0.30.
Women 65 years and older were not asked whether they had ever heard of HPV.
Excludes women who did not have a Papanicolaou test in the past 3 years.
Receipt of a Papanicolaou Test Among Women 30 Years and Older by Hysterectomy Status and Sociodemographic Characteristics, National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) (2010)
| Characteristic | Women Who Received a Papanicolaou Test Within the Past 3 Years, No. (% [95% CI]) | |
|---|---|---|
| Reporting Hysterectomy | Reporting No Hysterectomy | |
| Total | 1705 (64.8 [62.2–67.3]) | 7160 (80.7 [79.6–81.8]) |
| Age, y | ||
| 30–44 | 97 (87.8 [79.5–93.1]) | 2738 (87.8 [86.1–89.3]) |
| 45–64 | 836 (73.3 [69.8–76.6]) | 2947 (83.8 [82.0–85.4]) |
| ≥65 | 772 (50.8 [46.5–55.0]) | 1475 (58.4 [55.3–61.4]) |
| Race/ethnicity | ||
| Non-Hispanic white | 1126 (61.5 [58.4–64.4]) | 4179 (79.7 [78.2–81.1]) |
| Non-Hispanic black | 337 (76.3 [70.3–81.3]) | 1140 (82.2 [79.6–84.5]) |
| Hispanic or Latino | 190 (74.2 [66.9–80.3]) | 1337 (83.0 [80.3–85.4]) |
| Other | 52 (70.9 [54.4–83.3]) | 504 (85.4 [81.5–88.6]) |
| Education | ||
| Less than high school | 318 (56.2 [49.4–62.7]) | 1107 (66.7 [63.0–70.2]) |
| High school graduate or GED | 570 (64.1 [59.3–68.6]) | 1764 (73.0 [70.7–75.3]) |
| Some college | 523 (69.6 [65.0–73.8]) | 2090 (83.0 [81.0–84.8]) |
| College graduate or greater | 291 (66.1 [59.3–72.2]) | 2184 (89.3 [87.8–90.7]) |
| Missing | 3 | 15 |
| Proportion of poverty level, % | ||
| <200 | 832 (57.6 [53.2–61.8]) | 3194 (71.5 [69.6–73.3]) |
| 200 to <400 | 368 (61.0 [55.4–66.4]) | 1456 (79.7 [77.3–81.9]) |
| ≥400 | 505 (75.5 [71.4–79.2]) | 2508 (89.3 [87.8–90.7]) |
| Missing | 0 | 2 |
| Health care coverage | ||
| Private only | 334 (80.3 [74.7–84.9]) | 1996 (88.6 [86.9–90.1]) |
| Public only | 514 (52.9 [47.7–58.1]) | 1469 (69.3 [66.2–72.3]) |
| Public and private | 710 (63.9 [59.7–67.8]) | 2617 (85.0 [83.4–86.5]) |
| None | 144 (62.5 [52.1–71.9]) | 1064 (64.2 [60.8–67.5]) |
| Missing | 3 | 14 |
| Has a usual source of health care | ||
| Yes | 1625 (65.4 [62.7–67.9]) | 6379 (82.6 [81.5–83.7]) |
| No | 80 (50.8 [36.5–65.0]) | 781 (63.2 [58.8–67.4]) |
Abbreviation: GED, General Education Development.
All women 30 years and older, excluding women who report history of cervical cancer or an abnormal Papanicolaou test result in the past 3 years and women whose last Papanicolaou test was not a routine test. Percentages are weighted estimates. Missing responses are not included in the denominator. All analyses account for the stratification and clustering of data within the complex survey design of the NHIS.
Among women who reported a hysterectomy more than 3 years ago. Cases in which it could not be determined whether the hysterectomy or the Papanicolaou test came first were excluded.
Private insurance includes military insurance; public insurance includes Medicaid, Medicare, State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP), Indian Health Service (IHS), other public, and other government insurance types; single service plan is considered underinsured and is included with uninsured.