Conceived and designed the experiments: TMS AJM GAS EH EJN JPP KST MA THC JLM RB JL KMT. Performed the experiments: TMS AJM GAS EH EJN JPP KST CC MA THC PL JLM TB. Analyzed the data: TMS AJM GAS JLM TB JL KMT. Contributed to the writing of the manuscript: TMS AJM GAS EJN JPP JL KMT.
Dengue is a potentially fatal acute febrile illness caused by four mosquito-transmitted dengue viruses (DENV-1–4). Although dengue outbreaks regularly occur in many regions of the Pacific, little is known about dengue in the Republic of the Marshall Islands (RMI). To better understand dengue in RMI, we investigated an explosive outbreak that began in October 2011. Suspected cases were reported to the Ministry of Health, serum specimens were tested with a dengue rapid diagnostic test (RDT), and confirmatory testing was performed using RT-PCR and IgM ELISA. Laboratory-positive cases were defined by detection of DENV nonstructural protein 1 by RDT, DENV nucleic acid by RT-PCR, or anti-DENV IgM antibody by RDT or ELISA. Secondary infection was defined by detection of anti-DENV IgG antibody by ELISA in a laboratory-positive acute specimen. During the four months of the outbreak, 1,603 suspected dengue cases (3% of the RMI population) were reported. Of 867 (54%) laboratory-positive cases, 209 (24%) had dengue with warning signs, six (0.7%) had severe dengue, and none died. Dengue incidence was highest in residents of Majuro and individuals aged 10–29 years, and ∼95% of dengue cases were experiencing secondary infection. Only DENV-4 was detected by RT-PCR, which phylogenetic analysis demonstrated was most closely related to a virus previously identified in Southeast Asia. Cases of vertical DENV transmission, and DENV/
Dengue is the most common mosquito-borne viral illness in the world, and is endemic throughout the tropics and subtropics where ∼96 million cases occurred in 2010
Recent dengue outbreaks have been reported in the Pacific islands, including Fiji
Dengue was apparently first detected in the Republic of the Marshall Islands (RMI) during an outbreak in 1989 in which DENV-1 was isolated from cases on Majuro, Kwajalein and Ebon atolls (U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], unpublished data). In 1990 and 2004, DENV-2 and -1, respectively, were detected in serum specimens collected from RMI residents reported to CDC as having dengue-like illness (CDC, unpublished data). In 2010,
To enable early detection of dengue and other outbreak-prone diseases, in 2009 a surveillance system was initiated in RMI that included implementation of dengue rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs)
RMI is composed of 29 atolls and five islands with a total land mass of 70 square miles (sq mi) spread across ∼750,000 sq mi of ocean (
Surveillance data were collected during the outbreak, summarized weekly, and reported to WHO. After the outbreak had ended, a retrospective analysis of surveillance data was performed to: 1) describe the epidemiology of the 2011–2012 outbreak, including disease severity; 2) estimate the proportion of secondary DENV infections; 3) describe the molecular epidemiology of the DENV(s) responsible for the outbreak; and 4) identify the water containers producing vector mosquitoes.
Suspected cases identified at Majuro and Ebeye Hospitals were reported directly to MOH via the Dengue Surveillance Form (DSF;
Serum specimens were collected from all suspected dengue cases upon presentation to Majuro and Ebeye Hospitals and tested by RDT (Dengue Duo, Standard Diagnostics, Haryana, India). Convalescent specimens were collected upon discharge or during follow-up evaluation. For suspected dengue cases that presented to other health facilities in RMI, whole blood was collected at presentation and tested by RDT at the health facility. A convenience sample of both RDT-positive and-negative serum specimens were sent to CDC for confirmatory testing by multiplex, DENV-type-specific, real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR)
A suspected dengue case was an individual for whom a health care provider suspected dengue as the cause of illness and reported the case to MOH. A laboratory-positive case was a suspected dengue case for which: 1) DENV nucleic acid was detected by RT-PCR; 2) DENV non-structural protein 1 (NS1) was detected by RDT; or 3) anti-DENV IgM antibody was detected by RDT or ELISA. A laboratory-negative case was a suspected dengue case that had no laboratory diagnostic evidence of DENV infection. Dengue, dengue with warning signs, and severe dengue were defined according to 2009 WHO guidelines
A representative sample of all laboratory-positive cases was selected to estimate the rates of primary and secondary infection. Cases were stratified by age group with optimal allocation for comparison between age groups. Sample size was calculated to estimate the proportion of secondary infections by age group based on data from the 2010 dengue epidemic in Puerto Rico
Serum specimens in which DENV nucleic acid was detected and with CT values <25 were inoculated into cultures of C6/36 cells, in which growth of DENV was detected by RT-PCR and indirect immunofluorescence
Relative abundance and species composition of juvenile mosquito populations in aquatic container habitats were assessed in 155 households on Majuro atoll during 3–8 November, 2011. Sampling focused on four communities (Rita, Uliga, Long Island and Laura) where the incidence of suspected dengue was high during 10 October–5 November 2011. All outdoor container habitats at selected households were inspected for the presence of standing water, juvenile mosquitoes, and if >20 pupae were present in the container. Mosquito specimens were retained from a subset of samples from each container habitat class and preserved in ethanol (larvae) or reared to eclosion (pupae) for identification to species.
All surveillance data were entered into a Microsoft Access (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA) database at MOH. Rates of suspected and laboratory-positive dengue cases were calculated using population denominators from the 2011 RMI Census
This investigation underwent institutional review at CDC and was determined to be public health practice and not research; as such, Institutional Review Board approval was not required. All specimens tested in RMI were not anonymized to facilitate reporting of diagnostic test results to clinicians. All specimens sent to CDC were anonymized prior to shipment.
The first identified laboratory-positive case had onset of illness on October 14, 2011 and resided in Majuro atoll (
Laboratory case definition and date of illness onset were compiled as indicated. Only one date per week is shown on the x-axis.
Serum specimens were collected upon presentation from all patients with dengue-like illness. Specimens were collected a median of two days (25th–75th quartile: 1–3) post-onset of illness. Paired acute and convalescent specimens were available for 59 (3.7%) cases.
Of 1,603 suspected dengue cases identified during the outbreak (3.0% of RMI residents), 657 (41%) were laboratory-negative, 79 (4.9%) were not tested, and 867 (54%; 1.6% of RMI residents) were laboratory-positive. Of 1,379 specimens tested with the RDT in RMI, 626 (45%) were positive: 536 (86%) by detection of NS1, 73 (12%) by detection of anti-DENV IgM antibody, and 17 (2.7%) by detection of both NS1 and anti-DENV IgM antibody. From a convenience sample of 845 RDT-positive and -negative specimens sent to CDC and tested by RT-PCR, DENV-4 was detected in 482 (57%) and was the only DENV detected during the outbreak. Of the 363 specimens that tested negative by RT-PCR and were further tested by IgM ELISA at CDC, anti-DENV IgM antibody was detected in 45 (12%).
Laboratory-positive cases were identified from seven of the 25 inhabited atolls and islands that comprise RMI (
Laboratory case definition and atoll of residence were compiled as indicated. Asterisks indicate atolls with laboratory-positive cases. Ebeye island is located on Kwajalein atoll.
Most (72%) laboratory-positive cases were aged 10–29 years (
From a representative sample of 194 laboratory-positive acute specimens, 184 (95%) had evidence of secondary infection (
Following virus isolation and E gene sequencing, Bayesian phylogenetic analysis demonstrated that the virus circulating in RMI is distinct from other DENV-4 previously identified in the Pacific islands, and instead belongs to clade II of the Indonesian genotype that is geographically associated with Southeast Asia (
N = 40 E gene sequences (1,485 basepairs). Internal nodes supported by posterior probability. The dot indicates the DENV-4 isolated from the Republic of the Marshall Islands in 2011 (GenBank accession number JX891655).
Laboratory-positive cases were not significantly associated with sex, age, or ethnicity (
| Characteristic | All cases | Laboratory-positivecases | Laboratory-negativecases |
| N = 1,603 | N = 867 | N = 657 | |
| 750 (48) | 420 (50) | 289 (45) | |
| 20(0 days–89 years) | 20(0 days–86 years) | 20(0 days–89 years) | |
| Pacific IslanderAsianCaucasianOther | 1,294 (97)37 (2.8)2 (0.1)6 (0.4) | 677 (97)21 (3.0)1 (0.1)2 (0.3) | 553 (97)15 (2.6)1 (0.2)4 (0.7) |
| 1,241 (77) | 688 (79) | 495 (75) | |
| 160 (10) | |||
| 84 (5.2) | 40 (4.6) | 42 (6.4) | |
| 312 (19)205 (66)99 (32)5 (1.6)22 (7.1)50 (16)6 (1.9)69 (22) | |||
| 9 (0.6)2 (22)5 (56)2 (22) | 6 (0.7)1 (17)4 (67)1 (17) | 3 (0.5)1 (33)1 (33)1 (33) |
Numbers in bold indicate a significant difference in proportions (Chi-squared, p<0.05) between laboratory-positive and -negative cases.
*79 cases were not tested.
Sex was not reported for 34 cases.
Ethnicity was not reported for 264 cases.
Four infants aged <1 year tested positive with the RDT: three by detection of NS1, and one by detection of anti-DENV IgM antibody; all were hospitalized. One infant was a neonate male born to a febrile mother in whom NS1 was detected on the day of parturition. On day seven of life, the infant developed severe dengue with cyanosis and severe bleeding requiring blood transfusion. Both the baby and mother recovered and were ultimately discharged. As 111 pregnant women gave birth during the outbreak, the rate of documented vertical DENV transmission resulting in dengue during the outbreak was 0.9% (1/111). Four additional pregnant, laboratory-positive females were identified during the outbreak; all recovered without complication. No reported fetal losses or perinatal deaths were associated with maternal DENV infection during the outbreak.
An 11-year-old boy from Utrik atoll had onset of fever in early November and subsequently had streaks of blood in his stool. After being transported to Majuro Hospital, he was given intravenous ampicillin, cephazoline, and metronidazole for a presumptive diagnosis of typhoid fever; however, his fever persisted. White blood cell count, platelet count, hemoglobin, and hematocrit were normal. NS1 was detected on day 8 of illness, and
An 18-year-old male in his third month of treatment for leprosy was admitted with a two-day history of fever and malaise. On examination he was febrile with patchy nodular skin lesions on the trunk and extremities. NS1 and DENV-4 were detected in a serum specimen. His hospital course was unremarkable and he continued treatment for leprosy, including a decreased dose of prednisone. He was discharged on day six of hospitalization.
Mosquito larvae or pupae were detected at 87% of inspected homes (i.e., House Index) and in 64% of containers with standing water outside homes (i.e., Container Index), with an estimated density of 413 mosquito-positive containers per 100 households (i.e., Breteau Index) (
| Container Class(representative types) | Number of Containers per 100 Households (% of Water-filled Containers Inspected) | ||
| With Water | Larvae or Pupae Present | >20 Pupae Present | |
| 235 | 133 (57) | 17 (7) | |
| 76 | 67 (88) | 5 (7) | |
| 105 | 58 (56) | 4 (14) | |
| 28 | 21 (75) | 2 (7) | |
| 83 | 55 (67) | 1 (1) | |
| 46 | 38 (82) | 1 (3) | |
| 23 | 16 (69) | 1 (3) | |
| 54 | 24 (45) | 3 (5) | |
| Total | 650 | 413 (64) | 34 (5) |
A total of 738
Examples of habitat types in each container class are provided in
The epidemiologic characteristics of this outbreak were captured by improving public and clinical awareness of dengue, enhancing surveillance to enable rapid case reporting, and use of a RDT followed by confirmatory testing to define dengue cases. Pertinent findings include 3% of all RMI residents being reported as a suspected dengue case, laboratory confirmation of dengue in 3% of Majuro residents, hospitalization of 13% of dengue cases, and identification of water storage containers as prominent sources of vector mosquitoes. The prevalence of secondary infection in all age groups demonstrates that DENVs regularly circulate in RMI.
The rate of suspected dengue cases observed during this outbreak (3%) was similar to that recently reported from FSM and the Solomon Islands
Several studies have demonstrated that primary infection with DENV-4 infrequently causes clinically apparent illness
Interestingly, the DENV-4 that caused the RMI outbreak was distinct from other DENV-4 circulating previously in the Pacific, but was nearly identical to viruses isolated from dengue patients in 2012 from FSM and another with travel history to RMI. Moreover, the genetic relatedness of the DENV-4 from RMI to DENV-4 from Southeast Asia suggests that human travel from Southeast Asia resulted in the RMI outbreak, which subsequently spread to FSM. A similar chain of events enabled spread of DENV-4 throughout Pacific islands in 2009
Although
The high abundance of water storage containers infested with
This investigation was subject to several limitations. Because confirmatory diagnostic testing was not performed for nearly half of suspected cases that were tested only by RDT, which may yield false-negative test results
This outbreak demonstrated the acute burden that a dengue outbreak can have in a Pacific island population. To reduce the likelihood of future outbreaks, evidence-based behavioral and interventional approaches to reduce mosquito vector populations should be developed and routinely implemented. Dengue surveillance should continue to be strengthened in RMI and other Pacific island countries to rapidly detect and respond to outbreaks. In anticipation of a dengue vaccine, the age group of individuals affected by dengue in the Pacific should be elucidated to better inform vaccine campaigns.
(TIF)
Click here for additional data file.
(TIF)
Click here for additional data file.
We thank Duane Gubler for providing data from the 1989 RMI dengue outbreak response by CDC; Harry Savage for providing data from the 2010 RMI mosquito survey; Jane Gancio, Bong Villaroya, Cherri Casallo and Richard Trinidad for clinical support in Majuro and Ebeye Hospitals; Edlen Anzures for maintenance of the RMI Dengue Database; Richard Brostrom for clinical logistics support; the U.S. Department of Defense for providing vector control training and resources; and Ray A. Arthur and Catherine C. Chow for CDC outbreak response support and coordination, respectively. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.