Food purchased from prepared-food sources has become a major part of the American diet and is linked to increased rates of chronic disease. Many interventions targeting prepared-food sources have been initiated with the goal of promoting healthful options. The objective of this study was to provide a systematic review of interventions in prepared-food sources in community settings.
We used PubMed and Google Scholar and identified 13 interventions that met these criteria: 1) focused on prepared-food sources in public community settings, 2) used an impact evaluation, 3) had written documentation, and 4) took place after 1990. We conducted interviews with intervention staff to obtain additional information. Reviewers extracted and reported data in table format to ensure comparability.
Interventions mostly targeted an urban population, predominantly white, in a range of income levels. The most common framework used was social marketing theory. Most interventions used a nonexperimental design. All made use of signage and menu labeling to promote healthful food options. Several promoted more healthful cooking methods; only one introduced new healthful menu options. Levels of feasibility and sustainability were high; sales results showed increased purchasing of healthful options. Measures among consumers were limited but in many cases showed improved awareness and frequency of purchase of promoted foods.
Interventions in prepared-food sources show initial promising results at the store level. Future studies should focus on improved study designs, expanding intervention strategies beyond signage and assessing impact among consumers.
Obesity is a multifactorial disease that has many contributing factors, including the food environment. Food environments in which energy-dense prepared foods (ready-to-eat foods that can be eaten outside the home or brought back or delivered to the home to eat) are readily available are associated with the increasing prevalence of obesity (
This systematic review was designed to identify interventions in public prepared-food sources; to present data on strategy, study design, evaluation, process indicators, and impact for each intervention identified; and to suggest next steps in research, practice, and policy. We followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, which provide 27 checklist items that aim to standardize the structure of meta-analyses and ensure comprehensive reporting (
From September 2011 through January 2013, we used PubMed and Google Scholar to search peer-reviewed journals and Google to search “gray” literature for articles on interventions in prepared-food sources. Gray literature included newsletters, published (but not peer-reviewed) articles, policy briefs or reports, published trial materials, and conference presentations. Search terms for each engine included the following: “restaurant intervention,” “nutrition AND intervention,” “fast-food AND intervention,” “prepared food intervention,” “point of purchase food,” “healthy food choices,” and “restaurant health food choices.”
We initially identified 35 potential interventions. All identified food-source interventions were reviewed for inclusion according to the following criteria: 1) a focus on prepared-food sources in public community settings such as carryout, fast-food, and sit-down restaurants (although other intervention components could be included as part of the intervention); 2) a completed impact evaluation (eg, pre–post assessment, use of a comparison group, exposure assessment with or without a comparison group); 3) some form of written documentation (eg, peer-reviewed journal article, newsletter article, other published article, policy brief or report, published trial material, a project’s own website or conference presentation) that included a description of the implemented intervention and evaluation findings; and 4) an intervention start date after 1990. Of the original 35 interventions, 19 met these inclusion criteria.
For 4 of the 19 interventions, only website information was available, and because we were unable to obtain further information, these 4 were also excluded from our review. Of the 15 remaining, 2 interventions lacked information on study findings and were therefore excluded. These exclusions left 13 interventions for review, data extraction, and analysis.
The 2 primary reviewers (S.L.K., B.B.) independently extracted and analyzed data by reviewing all documents. The secondary reviewer (J.G.) developed the system for extracting data and coding variables. The secondary reviewer also resolved discrepancies noted by the 2 primary reviewers and identified and adjudicated other discrepancies that might affect reliability and analysis (
Primary reviewers were instructed to extract data for each variable and to organize data using the intervention as the unit of analysis. We attempted to contact a representative of each intervention to obtain more information. Seven of 13 intervention managers or lead researchers participated in semistructured telephone interviews or e-mail communications (or both) designed to gather additional information needed to complete the data tables and to resolve any inconsistencies. One intervention (Baltimore Healthy Carryouts) was implemented by our team. After the interventions were reviewed, we summarized data in 3 tables: background and intervention approach, evaluation methods used, and study findings. Within each table, we grouped restaurants into 4 categories according to similar characteristics: specialty restaurants, chain restaurants, small local restaurants, and mixed types of restaurants (both local and chain) that did not share characteristics with other restaurants or whose characteristics were not well defined. The primary reviewers organized the information about each study into these tables. The secondary reviewer confirmed data accuracy by using initial review findings, e-mail correspondence, interview transcripts, and extraction and reporting guidelines.
We implemented previously used techniques (
Of the 13 interventions (
| Characteristic | Baltimore Healthy Carryouts ( | Good for You ( | Steps to a Healthier Salinas ( | Horgen and Brownell 2002 ( |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| Peer-reviewed articles; conference presentation; website | Peer-reviewed article; e-mail correspondence | Peer-reviewed articles; interview; e-mail correspondence; intervention materials | Peer-reviewed article; interview |
|
| Baltimore; African American; low-income; urban | Minnesota; Target store customers | Salinas, California; low-income; mostly Mexican American | New Haven, Connecticut; delicatessen customers; mostly white, upper-middle class |
|
| Social cognitive theory; Social marketing | Not specified | Socioecological model; asset-based community development | Matching model; health belief model |
|
| Awareness; availability; affordability; consumption | Awareness; consumption | Awareness; consumption; availability | Awareness; consumption; affordability |
|
| Carryout restaurants serving mainly deep-fried foods | Cafeteria in large general merchandise/department store | Mexican-style restaurants | Delicatessen |
|
| Low-fat, low-cholesterol entrées, sides, and beverages | 15 Low-fat items on menu | Healthier preparations for dishes; replacement of lard with vegetable oil for cooking | Low-fat meals and sides |
|
| ||||
|
| Menu board; menu labeling; point-of-purchase posters | Menu labeling; point-of-purchase materials (table tents, tray liners) | Point-of-purchase materials (logo on menu and signage) | Price reduction messages; point-of purchase materials (signs, posters) |
|
| Fresh fruits, yogurts, healthful sides, and grilled chicken sandwich | None | Healthful preparation strategies; fresh fruit juices | None |
|
| Reduced-price combination meals | None | Coupons (10% discount) | 20%–30% price reduction of low-fat items |
|
| None | None | None | None |
|
| None | None | Healthy Nutrition Tool kit; give-aways | None |
|
| Semi-structured interview with customers (N = 50) and owners (N = 12); focus groups, conjoint analysis (N = 50) | Customer survey of interest in buying lower-fat foods at Target Food Avenue | Surveys of local taquerias; work with owners to identify intervention strategies | Informal discussions with restaurant managers and staff |
Includes restaurants, such as carryouts, taquerias, and delicatessen cafés, that focused on specialty foods; it excludes chain fast-food restaurants.
| Characteristic | Coeur en Santé St-Henri ( | TrEAT Yourself Well ( | Tandon et al 2011 ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Peer-reviewed article | Peer-reviewed article; e-mail correspondence | Peer-reviewed article; e-mail correspondence |
|
| Montreal; restaurant customers; low-income | San Diego area; restaurant customers; mostly white | Seattle and San Diego; children aged 6–11 years and parents |
|
| Social learning theory | Theory of reasoned action; social marketing | None specified |
|
| Awareness; consumption | Awareness; consumption | Awareness; consumption |
|
| Fast-food restaurant and family-style restaurant | 4 chain restaurants | Chain restaurants |
|
| Low-fat, high-fiber items on menus | Low-fat menu items containing fruits and vegetables | Chain restaurant foods |
|
| |||
|
| Menu labeling | Point-of-purchase materials (table tents, posters) | Menu labeling |
|
| Recipe modification to increase fiber or decrease fat | None | None |
|
| None | Discount cards | None |
|
| Media (newspaper, telephone, leaflets) | Community events and food tasting; media (television, magazines, newspaper) | None |
|
| None | Wait-staff incentives | None |
|
| Community informants identify popular restaurants; dietitian review of menu options via interviews with kitchen staff supervisor and suppliers | None | None |
| Characteristic | Shape Up Somerville ( | Smart Menu Program ( | The Healthy Options Program ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Peer-reviewed articles; website | Peer-reviewed articles; e-mail correspondence | Peer-reviewed article; website; e-mail correspondence |
|
| Somerville, Massachusetts; restaurant customers; students in 1st–3rd grade | Tacoma-Pierce County, Washington; restaurant customers; mostly white | Rural Iowa; mostly white |
|
| Community-based participatory research | Diffusion of innovations | Social cognitive theory |
|
| Awareness; availability | Awareness; consumption | Awareness; consumption |
|
| Various participating restaurants | Various participating locally owned restaurants | Various locally owned restaurants |
|
| Half-size portions; low-fat milk or water | Meal and dessert items | Low-fat dressings, milk, meat, sides, breakfast items, desserts, whole-wheat bread |
|
| |||
|
| Menu labeling; point-of-purchase materials (logo and signs, menu inserts) | Menu labeling | Point-of-purchase materials (table placard, poster) |
|
| Half-sized portions of entrées; fruit and vegetable side dishes; low-fat milk or water | Encouragement of addition of healthful items, preparations, smaller portion sizes | None |
|
| None | None | None |
|
| Improved walkability and environmental policies; community advocates established; farmers market program; newspaper ads | Media (newsletters, newspapers, websites) | Media (newspaper) |
|
| None | Free menu analysis | None |
|
| Meetings, focus groups, and interviews with owners/managers; advisory council; approval criteria were refined with feedbacks from restaurant owners and managers; unable to complete 3 focus groups with restaurants | Menu labeling literature review; consulted food industry representative and health advisory group; no formal formative research phase. | Pilot survey to indicate customer preferences; presented to owners |
Includes small, locally owned “mom-and-pop” establishments that include but are not limited to take-out and sit-down restaurants and restaurants that focused on specialty foods; it excludes chain restaurants.
| Characteristic | Healthy Howard Initiative ( | Healthy Restaurant Program ( | Winners Circle Healthy Dining Program ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Interview; website; printed materials; e-mail correspondence | Peer-reviewed article; research report; interview | Peer-reviewed article; conference presentation; website; e-mail correspondence |
|
| Howard County, Maryland; restaurant customers | Seoul, South Korea; restaurant customers | 65 North Carolina counties; mixed race/ethnicity |
|
| Community-based environmental change initiative | Community capacity analysis | Social marketing; community-based environmental-change initiative |
|
| Awareness; consumption | Awareness; consumption | Awareness; consumption |
|
| Various participating restaurants | Various participating restaurants | Various participating restaurants |
|
| Healthful entrées that meet nutritional criteria | Healthful menu items that meet nutritional criteria | Meals, side items, snacks and beverages good for “heart health” |
|
| |||
|
| Menu labeling; point-of-purchase materials (window decal and certificate, nutrition sheets) | Menu labeling; point-of-purchase materials (photos, menu boards, posters, logo on restaurant) | Point-of-purchase materials (logo on menu, promoted items) |
|
| Trans fat-free; healthful menu options | Foods that meet nutritional standards | None |
|
| Discounts (planned, not yet implemented) | None | None |
|
| Media (newspaper, magazine, websites); community events | Media (newspaper, website); community events | Media (billboards, television) |
|
| Comply with the “Clean Indoor Air Act”; pass food inspections; allergen labeling on menu | None | Nutritional information in booklets or brochures in some locations |
|
| None | Survey of customers and restaurant workers for information on how to design intervention; focus groups with restaurant workers; in-depth interviews with consumers | Pilot in 2 North Carolina counties; intercept interviews |
Includes restaurants (both local and chain) that did not share characteristics with other intervention restaurants or whose characteristics were not well defined.
Most interventions (n = 9) took place in urban settings; 3 interventions focused on mixed urban and rural populations, and one focused on rural settings. Interventions were conducted in various regions of the United States: 4 in the Northeast, 4 in the West, 2 in the Midwest, and 1 in the Southeast. Only 2 interventions took place outside the United States (
Ten interventions explicitly stated the theoretical frameworks that guided their design (
Overall, the 13 interventions shared similar goals. All sought to promote more healthful menu items at prepared-food sources with the associated goal of increasing sales of these foods. Some interventions had additional goals. The larger goal of Shape Up Somerville (
Three interventions (
All interventions focused on identifying and promoting existing healthful food options at prepared-food sources as the primary intervention strategy. Five interventions identified specific nutritional criteria for a food to be considered healthful (Coeur en Santé [
Six interventions worked with restaurant owners and staff to develop more healthful recipes, usually by using lower-fat cooking methods (
All 13 interventions used some form of signage to promote more healthful options. Most interventions (n = 10) used some form of menu labeling, usually a symbol to indicate more healthful choices. Baltimore Healthy Carryouts (
Four interventions sought to reduce the consumers’ cost for the more healthful items. Steps to a Healthier Salinas (
Four interventions did not promote their programs outside the prepared-food sources or in the general community. Of the 7 interventions that promoted their programs widely, a variety of approaches were used, including newspaper advertisements (n = 5), promotion at community events (n = 3), and leaflets and newsletters (n = 3). These promotions were intended to increase awareness of the program and to direct consumers to prepared-food sources participating in the intervention.
Most interventions were nonexperimental interventions in which participation by the prepared-food sources was voluntary (n = 10). Two interventions had a quasi-experimental design: Shape up Somerville (
| Characteristic | Baltimore Healthy Carryouts ( | Good for You ( | Steps to a Healthier Salinas ( | Horgen and Brownell 2002 ( |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| Experimental design; pre–post assessment (n = 8) | Nonexperimental; pre–post sales analysis, broken down by quarter (n = 7) | Nonexperimental; no pre–post assessment; intervention trial, voluntary participation; no comparison group (n = 16) | Nonexperimental; pre–post assessment (n = 1) |
|
| Informal observation; staff reports; interviews with carryout owners or staff | Launched simultaneously in all Target Food Avenue restaurants; not assessed at individual store level | Assessments, discussion with health educators | Informal visits, daily check-in |
|
| Direct observation | None | Surveys with store owners; informal observation | Informal visits, daily check-in |
|
| Sales | Sales | None | Sales |
|
| Purchasing; awareness; self-reported body mass index | None | Modified Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System | Behavior |
Includes restaurants, such as carryouts, taquerias, and delicatessen cafés, that focused on specialty foods; it excludes chain fast-food restaurants.
Feasibility assessment measures include acceptability, operability, and perceived sustainability.
Process evaluation measures include dose, reach, and fidelity, which indicate how well the program was implemented according to plan.
Consumer impact measures included psychosocial, behavioral, and health outcomes.
| Characteristic | Coeur en Santé St-Henri ( | TrEAT Yourself Well ( | Tandon et al 2011 ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Nonexperimental; no pre–post assessment (n = 2) | Quasi-experimental; no pre–post assessment; comparison regions (n = 4) | Pre–post assessment; comparison counties |
|
| None | None | None specified |
|
| None | None | None specified |
|
| None | None | None |
|
| Purchasing; attitudes | Awareness; attitudes | Awareness; behavior (calories consumed) |
Feasibility assessment measures include acceptability, operability, and perceived sustainability.
Process evaluation measures include dose, reach, and fidelity, which indicate how well the program was implemented according to plan.
Consumer impact measures included psychosocial, behavioral, and health outcomes.
| Characteristic | Shape Up Somerville ( | Smart Menu Program ( | The Healthy Options Program ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Quasi-experimental; nonexperimental for restaurant portion of intervention; intervention trial, voluntary participation (n = 21) | Nonexperimental; pre–post assessment; intervention trial, voluntary participation; no comparison group (n = 6) | Nonexperimental; pre–post assessment (n = 4) |
|
| Environmental change assessment; owners’ compliance and perceived impact | Interviews with restaurant owners or managers | Interviews with owner and staff |
|
| Extensive process evaluation; participation and adherence to intervention elements | Observation of nutrition information being posted | None |
|
| Owner survey (menu changes, sales, nutrition awareness) | Sales | Sales |
|
| None for restaurant intervention; assessment at child and household level (change in body mass index) | Awareness; behavior | Awareness; behavior |
Includes small, locally owned “mom-and-pop” establishments that include but are not limited to take-out and sit-down restaurants and restaurants that focused on specialty foods; it excludes chain restaurants.
Feasibility assessment measures include acceptability, operability, and perceived sustainability.
Process evaluation measures include dose, reach, and fidelity, which indicate how well the program was implemented according to plan.
Consumer impact measures included psychosocial, behavioral, and health outcomes.
| Characteristic | Healthy Howard Initiative ( | Healthy Restaurant Program ( | Winners Circle Healthy Dining Program ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Nonexperimental design; intervention trial, voluntary participation; no comparison group | Nonexperimental design; pre–post assessment; intervention trial, voluntary participation; no comparison group | Nonexperimental; intervention trial, voluntary participation; cross-sectional survey of community awareness of program; no comparison group |
|
| Restaurant owner or manager survey; focus group; recipe analysis | Interviews with chefs; survey of restaurant managers or staff | Survey of managers |
|
| Informal observation, telephone communication; annual health inspection; recertification every 2 years | Annual menu analysis; annual observation | Tracked reach and dose using Winner’s Circle team reporting forms; menu review |
|
| Restaurant owner or manager survey (recall of sales) | Restaurant owner survey | None |
|
| Psychosocial, behavioral survey | Awareness; attitudes | Awareness |
Includes restaurants (both local and chain) that did not share characteristics with other intervention restaurants or whose characteristics were not well defined.
Feasibility assessment measures include acceptability, operability, and perceived sustainability.
Process evaluation measures include dose, reach, and fidelity, which indicate how well the program was implemented according to plan.
Consumer impact measures included psychosocial, behavioral, and health outcomes.
Most interventions (n = 8) collected information on feasibility. In general, this information was in the form of interviews and informal discussions with owners and managers of the prepared-food sources. These same 8 interventions also conducted some form of process evaluation (usually through store visits) to assess, for example, whether signage was displayed and healthful options were available.
Overall, the level of feasibility was moderate to high for intervention implementation (
| Characteristic | Baltimore Healthy Carryouts ( | Good for You ( | Steps to a Healthier Salinas ( | Horgen and Brownell 2002 ( |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| High acceptability and fidelity for Phase 1 and Phase 3; medium acceptability and operability for Phase 2; high dose received | Not assessed | Medium feasibility; medium reach to owners; moderate to high fidelity in terms of changes to menu items | Assessed but results not reported |
|
| Increase in sales of promoted items | Increase in sales of promoted items | Not assessed | Increase in sales of promoted items, especially with price reductions |
|
| Not assessed | Not assessed | Assessed but results not reported | Assessed but results not reported because of low response rate |
|
| Increased purchasing | Not assessed | Not assessed | Not assessed |
|
| Community members’ positive response toward the intervention | Seasonality of sales of some foods (salad, frozen yogurt) | Mistrust of health educators by restaurant owners | Health messages not very effective |
|
| Low implementation cost | Sales of labeled foods remained high | High sustainability: most signage still displayed 4 years later | Went out of business |
|
| Disseminated citywide as a public market carryout strategy “Get Fresh Public Markets” | Supports effectiveness of menu labeling | Considering permits based on healthful food offerings | Subsidies on healthful foods can increase sales |
Includes restaurants, such as carryouts, taquerias, and delicatessen cafés, that focused on specialty foods; it excludes chain fast-food restaurants.
| Characteristic | Coeur en Santé St-Henri ( | TrEAT Yourself Well ( | Tandon et al 2011 ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| High acceptability among owners and customers | Not assessed | None |
|
| Not assessed | Not assessed | None |
|
| Awareness of campaign; intentions to eat healthier | High awareness; beliefs about healthful food | High awareness of nutrition information |
|
| Increased purchasing in family-style restaurant compared with fast-food restaurant | Increased purchasing of healthful foods | No difference in mean calories consumed between or within groups |
|
| 25% of customers reported that they eat at the restaurant at least once a week; health and taste top 2 reasons for selecting healthful items | Demographic variables had no effect on awareness | No information |
|
| Permanent implementation of some healthful foods | No information | No information |
|
| Evidence for feasibility of intervention in low-income setting | Moderate support for promotional campaigns as intervention strategy | None |
| Characteristic | Shape Up Somerville ( | Smart Menu Program ( | The Healthy Options Program ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Low acceptability; medium reach | High acceptability; low feasibility; low reach; low operability | Moderate acceptability of promoted items; high fidelity; high feasibility |
|
| 4/10 Restaurants changed menus; 6/10 reported customers ordering from Shape Up Somerville options; 7/10 believed beneficial to participate; 7/10 were more aware of nutrition; 4/10 thought customers were more aware of nutrition | Fewer average calories, lower levels of fat and sodium per entrée sold | No significant change in ordering |
|
| Not assessed at restaurant level | High level of awareness; no impact on knowledge reported | Moderate awareness |
|
| Not assessed at restaurant level | 20.4% of customers reported ordering lower calories, 16.5% lower fat | 1/3 of customers reported materials influenced ordering |
|
| Body mass index among children reduced by 0.1005 | Higher entrée cost associated with more calories and fat consumed; consumers chose smaller, cheaper entrées | None |
|
| Low-medium: more than 50% of restaurants were noncompliant at follow-up | Medium: resource-intensive intervention. | High: materials stayed in place |
|
| Needed a stronger prepared-food source component | Success for calorie-labeling policy | Possibilities for combination with other intervention strategies |
Includes small, locally owned “mom-and-pop” establishments that include but are not limited to take-out and sit-down restaurants and restaurants that focused on specialty foods; it excludes chain restaurants.
| Characteristic | Healthy Howard Initiative ( | Healthy Restaurant Program ( | Winners Circle Healthy Dining Program ( |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Moderate reach (currently on-going) | Increasing reach; improved ratings of participating restaurants | High feasibility; medium-low reach |
|
| Not assessed (surveys not performed) | Increase in sales of promoted items; sodium and fat in foods significantly decreased | Not assessed |
|
| Assessed but not reported | High customer acceptability | Low awareness |
|
| Assessed but not reported | Not assessed | Medium use of label for food choice |
|
| None | None | None |
|
| Low implementation cost | High: 85/96 of restaurants are maintaining program | Low-cost, easily implemented |
|
| Voluntary program | Ordinance for the Healthy Restaurant Program | No links with policy |
Includes restaurants (both local and chain) that did not share characteristics with other intervention restaurants or whose characteristics were not well defined.
Findings on process evaluation were more variable. Several interventions were public health interventions with open volunteer enrollment. Many of these interventions had low reach, when assessed by counting customers. We found that interventions had particular difficulty in recruiting restaurants, which was reflected in low reach among restaurants (
Seven interventions assessed the impact of the intervention on prepared-food sources. Four of these 7 interventions (Baltimore Healthy Carryouts, Healthy Restaurant, Healthy Howard, and Shape Up Somerville) interviewed food-source owners to assess whether sales of healthful options increased. Four used data from food-source registers; 2 interventions collected sales receipts (Baltimore Healthy Carryouts [
When sales were assessed, 5 interventions showed an increase in unit sales of promoted foods. Three interventions — Horgen and Brownell (
Eleven interventions collected information on the impact of the intervention on consumers (
Of the 6 interventions that reported an assessment of psychosocial factors among consumers, most (n = 4) found an increased awareness of the intervention and its goals. Of these, Coeur en Santé (
Among the 7 interventions that assessed the impact of the intervention on consumer food-related behaviors, only 5 interventions reported results. Four of the 5 interventions (Baltimore Healthy Carryouts [
This is the first systematic review of interventions in community-based prepared-food sources. Results are promising, showing that cost-effective methods (eg, labeling foods as healthful) may have a significant impact on prepared-food source sales and customer behavior. Most approaches centered on signage to promote existing healthful food choices. Several worked with kitchen staff to improve low-fat food preparation practices, and several conducted formal menu analyses to determine more healthful choices for promotion. These strategies, though resource intensive, show that it is important to engage prepared-food source staff in determining more healthful options.
Although interventions in prepared-food sources are increasingly being considered viable public health interventions, it is clear from this review that the evidence base for these interventions is deficient. Study designs tended to lack comparison groups, treatment conditions were not randomly assigned, and selection criteria were not readily apparent; these inadequacies cast doubt on the generalizability of findings.
Many of the interventions included in this review were not formal studies but rather certification or campaign programs operated by local health departments. These programs were voluntary, which may explain why they varied in levels of reach. Low reach may have been due to the actual burden placed on restaurant owners by the intervention or the lack of potential benefits perceived by them. Partnerships between local public health departments and academic institutions may help overcome some of these limitations through improved social marketing of program strategies and benefits. For example, local public health departments could initiate the intervention and manage recruitment while an academic institution partner conducts a full impact assessment, including psychosocial surveys and sales data collection.
We found no clear preference for a conceptual or behavior-change framework. A few interventions used social marketing approaches, but these interventions generally did not incorporate key social marketing components, such as formative research, audience segmentation, or targeting of messages (
Although many interventions showed promising results, most lacked adequate measurement of the impact of the intervention on consumers. Of studies that examined consumer outcomes, most assessed only awareness of the health promotion campaign and food purchasing frequency. More sophisticated assessments — based on behavior-change theories — are needed to evaluate such outcomes as food purchasing patterns and dietary intake.
Almost half of the interventions lacked formal formative research — a major omission, especially considering that food environment research is an emerging area of public health programming. Formative research involves qualitative and quantitative data collection, which aids in program development (
Another approach worth exploring is price changes. Two interventions showed positive results by reducing food prices (Baltimore Health Carryouts [
Our findings parallel in many ways the findings of recent interventions in small retail food stores (
This systematic review has some limitations. Many of the interventions reviewed were implemented by health departments that lacked the resources to conduct comprehensive evaluations and publish the findings in peer-reviewed publications. Thus, we included findings from the gray literature. Because of the wide variability in measures used and in impact assessments, we were not able to develop summary estimates or compare measures or impacts directly among interventions. These limitations emphasize the need for standardization of measures used by interventions and the need for further reviews that assess different strategies (
Our review lays the groundwork for further exploration of strategies to increase more healthful food options in community-based prepared-food sources. Many interventions showed that changing the prepared-food environment may improve sales and awareness of more healthful foods and improve purchasing and consumption behaviors. Interventions can be strengthened through comprehensive formative research and quantitative assessments of process and impacts. With these additions, future studies will be able to assess the relative effectiveness of different strategies and create standards of practice in prepared-food sources.
This review was supported by a Commissioned Analysis grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s Healthy Eating Research program. Dr Gittelsohn’s work in the study was supported in part by a research grant from the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (no. U54HD070725), which is cofunded by the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development and the Office of Behavioral and Social Sciences Research at the National Institutes of Health. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the funders.
The opinions expressed by authors contributing to this journal do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the Public Health Service, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or the authors' affiliated institutions.
| Topic | Reviewer 1 long response | Reviewer 1 short summary response | Reviewer 2 long response | Reviewer 2 short summary response | Adjudication (as it appears in the final table) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Project name | |||||
|
| |||||
| Data sources | |||||
|
| |||||
| Target population (ethnicity, age group, geographic location, etc.) | |||||
|
| |||||
| Model/Theory | |||||
|
| |||||
| Goal or Purpose of the trial (increase availability, increase sales, modify consumer diet, etc.) | |||||
|
| |||||
| Food (foods that were the focus of the intervention) | |||||
|
| |||||
| Intervention strategies: signage | |||||
|
| |||||
| Intervention strategies: availability of healthy foods | |||||
|
| |||||
| Intervention strategies: pricing or cost | |||||
|
| |||||
| Intervention strategies: community components | |||||
|
| |||||
| Intervention strategies: other | |||||
|
| |||||
| Study design | |||||
|
| |||||
| Formative research | |||||
|
| |||||
| Feasibility assessment (acceptability, operability, perceived sustainability) | |||||
|
| |||||
| Process evaluation (how well the program was implemented according to plan) | |||||
|
| |||||
| Prepared-food source impact measures | |||||
|
| |||||
| Consumer impact measures (psychosocial, behavioral, health outcomes) | |||||
|
| |||||
| Feasibility and process results | |||||
|
| |||||
| Prepared-food source impact results | |||||
|
| |||||
| Consumer psychosocial Impact results | |||||
|
| |||||
| Consumer behavioral impact results | |||||
|
| |||||
| Other results | |||||
|
| |||||
| Sustainability | |||||
|
| |||||
| Policy results, implications | |||||