Emerg Infect DisEmerging Infect. DisEIDEmerging Infectious Diseases1080-60401080-6059Centers for Disease Control and Prevention23460990355906612-146310.3201/eid1902.121463Letters to the EditorLetterToscana Virus Isolated from Sandflies, TunisiaToscana Virus from Sandflies,
TunisiaBichaudLaurence1DachraouiKhalil1PiorkowskiGéraldineChelbiIfhemMoureauGregoryCherniSaifedineDe LamballerieXavierSakhriaSoniaCharrelRémi N.2ZhiouaElyes2Author affiliations: Aix-Marseille University (AMU, IRD, EHESP),
Marseille, France (L. Bichaud, G. Piorkowski, G. Moureau, X. De Lamballerie,
R.N. Charrel); IHU Méditerranée Infection, Marseille (L. Bichaud, X.
De Lamballerie, R.N. Charrel); Institut Pasteur, Tunis, Tunisia (K. Dachraoui, I. Chelbi, S. Cherni,
S. Sakhria, E. Zhioua)Address for correspondence: Remi N. Charrel, Unite des Virus
Emergents, UMR190 “Emergence des Pathologies Virales,” Faculte de
Medecine, 27 Blvd Jean Moulin, 13005 Marseille, France; email: remi.charrel@univ-amu.fr22013192322324Keywords: Toscana virussandfliesvirusesTunisiaPhlebotomus perniciosusPhlebotomus perfiliewiPhlebovirusBunyaviridae
To the Editor: Toscana virus (TOSV; genus Phlebovirus,
family Bunyaviridae) is transmitted by sandflies, mostly the species
Phlebotomus perniciosus and P. perfiliewi (1). Initially discovered in central
Italy, TOSV was recently identified in other European countries (i.e., Portugal, Spain,
France, Croatia, and Turkey) (2).
TOSV is a primary cause of aseptic meningitis during warm months (2). A seroprevalence study suggested that TOSV is
present in Tunisia and may cause neuroinvasive infections, but definitive evidence of
TOSV circulation has not been possible because it is difficult to distinguish from the
antigenically related phlebovirus Punique virus (3,4); both viruses are members of the species Sandfly
fever Naples virus. We investigated the prevalence of TOSV among sandflies
in northern Tunisia.
A total of 5,288 sandflies (3,547 females, 1,740 males) were collected during
June–October 2010 by using CDC light traps (John W. Hock Company, Gainesville,
FL, USA) at Utique (37°08′N, 7°74′E), a focus for visceral
leishmaniasis in northern Tunisia. Sandflies were separated by sex and trapping nights
and pooled with >30 specimens by pool. Pools were processed as
described (4) and subjected to
PCR detection of phlebovirus RNA targeting 2 genes independently (4–6) and virus isolation onto Vero cells. Of 249 pools
processed, 8 strains of phleboviruses were isolated: 2 TOSV, 3 Punique virus, and 3
other phleboviruses currently being characterized.
TOSV strains were obtained from 2 pools of sandflies trapped in September 2010, T152 and
T166, consisting of 30 males and 30 females, respectively. These pools were positive for
TOSV RNA by sequencing of 2 PCR products (201-nt and 280-nt sections in the large [L]
and small [S] gene segments, respectively). Supernatant of the third passage was
prepared for electron microscopy, which showed spherical and pleomorphic structures,
80–120 nm in diameter, compatible with viruses of the family
Bunyaviridae. Complete genome sequencing was then done by using the
Ion PGM Sequencer (Life Technologies SAS, Saint Aubin, France) (7); a total of 165,307 reads were obtained, of
which 135,700 matched with the sequence of TOSV Iss.PhL3 used as reference. The viral
genome of TOSV Tunisia-2010-T152 (GenBank accession nos. JX867534–JX867536) was
composed of 12,488 nt; the complete sequence consisted of 1,869 nt, 4,215 nt, and 6,404
nt for the S, medium [M], and L RNA segments, respectively. The partial S sequence of
the TOSV Tunisia-2010-T166 strain (GenBank accession nos. JX867537–JX867539) was
identical to that of T152, but 1 synonymous mutation was observed in the partial L
sequence and 1 nonsynonymous mutation in the partial M sequence (I906V).
The TOSV Tunisia-2010-T152 strain was aligned with homologous sequences retrieved from
the GenBank database. Genetic distances were calculated at the amino acid and nucleotide
levels by using the p-distance algorithm (Technical Appendix Tables 1–3). Phylogenetic studies were performed
by using the neighbor-joining method in MEGA5 (8) (Figure). The
robustness of the nodes was tested by 1,000 bootstrap replications. We found that TOSV
Tunisia-2010-T152 was most closely related to the prototype strain from Italy, Iss.PhL3,
with nucleotide/amino acid distances of 0.031/0.052, 0.032/0.073, and 0.039/0.012 for
the S, M, and L RNA sequences, respectively. Together, these genetic distances and
phylogram topologies indicate that TOSV Tunisia-2010-T152 is most closely related to
strains within the Italian lineage, although it may represent a distinct sublineage,
more distantly related to strains belonging to the Spanish lineage (9).
Phylogenetic analysis of 3 segments of Toscana virus (TOSV) isolates from pools
of sandflies collected in Tunisia and homologous sequences of other selected
phleboviruses. A) Large segments; B) medium segments; C) small segments.
Sequences are identified by virus name or acronym, strain name, and GenBank
accession number. Scale bars indicate nucleotide substitutions per site. TEHV,
Tehran virus; SFNV, sandfly fever Naples virus; PNQV, Punique virus; RVFV, Rift
Valley fever virus; ARBV, Arbia virus; CHIOS, phlebovirus Chios-A; CFUV, Corfou
virus; SFSV, sandfly fever Sicilian virus; UUKV, Uukuniemi virus.
Concomitantly with virus isolation, the phenology of sandfly species was studied during
May–November 2010. Sandflies were identified, and the density was calculated as
described (10). Most of the
sandflies belonged to the subgenus Larroussius (98.3%). P.
perniciosus sandflies were the most abundant species (71.74%), followed by
P. longicuspis (17.47%) and P. perfiliewi (8.82%).
Other sandfly species, such as Phlebotomus
(Phlebotomus) papatasi,
Phlebotomus (Paraphlebotomus)
sergenti, Sergentomyia minuta parotti, S.
christophersi, and S. antennata were found, but these were
much less abundant. The phenology of 3 main sandfly species showed 2 main peaks: 1 small
peak in June and a second, larger peak during September–October (Technical Appendix Figure).
In summary, of a total of 5,288 sandflies collected, 2 pools were positive for TOSV,
yielding an infection rate of 0.03%. A similar infection rate was observed in Spain
(0.05%) (9); however, the
infection rates in Italy (0.22%) and in France (0.29%) are substantially higher (1,6). The isolation of TOSV from male and female
sandflies suggests transovarial transmission in nature, as reported in Italy and Spain
(1,9). In southern European countries, TOSV is mostly
transmitted by P. perniciosus and P.
perfiliewi sandflies (1,6,9), whereas P. perniciosus, P.
longicuspis, and P. perfiliewi are the most abundant
sandfly species in northern Tunisia. It is therefore probable that TOSV is transmitted
by sandfly species of the subgenus Larroussius.
We found that 2 phleboviruses belonging to the Sandfly fever Naples
virus species, TOSV and Punique virus, are cocirculating in northern
Tunisia. This finding calls for further investigation of these viruses’ potential
effect on human health in this area.
Technical Appendix
Genetic pairwise distances between Toscana virus strains and selected
phleboviruses and phenology of sandflies collected in Utique, Governorate of
Bizerte, Tunisia.
These authors contributed equally to this manuscript.
These authors contributed equally to this manuscript.
This study was funded in part by the French “Agence Nationale de la
Recherche” and “Agence inter-établissements de recherche pour
le développement” through the MIE Phlebo-MED project, by European
Virus Archive within the European FP7 CAPACITIES Project GA no. 228292, and by the
Institut Pasteur, Tunis, Tunisia.
ReferencesVeraniP,
CiulfoliniMG,
CaciolliS,
RenziA,
NicolettiL,
SabatinelliG, Ecology of viruses isolated from sand flies on Italy and
characterization of a new phlebovirus (Arbia virus).Am J Trop Med Hyg.
1988;38:433–93128131CharrelRN,
GallianP,
Navarro-MariJM,
NicolettiL,
PapaA,
Sánchez-SecoMP, Emergence of Toscana virus in Europe.Emerg Infect Dis.
2005;11:1657–6310.3201/eid1111.05086916318715BahriO,
FazaaO, Ben
Alaya-BouafifN,
BouloyM,
TrikiH,
BouattourA. Role of Toscana
virus in meningo-encephalitis in Tunisia[in French]Pathol Biol (Paris).
2011;59:e125–7
. Epub 2010 Apr 720378279ZhiouaE,
MoureauG,
ChelbiI,
NinoveL,
BichaudL,
DerbaliM, Punique virus, a novel phlebovirus, related to sandfly fever
Naples virus, isolated from sandflies collected in Tunisia.J Gen Virol.
2010;91:1275–83
and. 10.1099/vir.0.019240-020089800Sánchez-SecoMP,
EchevarríaJM,
HernándezL,
EstévezD,
Navarro-MaríJM,
TenorioA. Detection and
identification of Toscana and other phleboviruses by RT-nested-PCR assays
with degenerated primers.J Med Virol.
2003;71:140–910.1002/jmv.1046512858420CharrelRN,
IzriA,
TemmamS,
DelaunayP,
TogaI,
DumonH, Cocirculation of 2 genotypes of Toscana virus, southeastern
France.Emerg Infect Dis.
2007;13:465–810.3201/eid1303.06108617552102RothbergJM,
HinzW,
RearickTM,
SchultzJ,
MileskiW,
DaveyM, An integrated semiconductor device enabling non-optical genome
sequencing.Nature.
2011;475:348–5210.1038/nature1024221776081TamuraK,
PetersonD,
PetersonN,
StecherG,
NeiM,
KumarS. MEGA5: Molecular
Evolutionary Genetics Analysis using maximum likelihood, evolutionary
distance, and maximum parsimony methods.Mol Biol Evol.
2011;28:2731–9Epub 2011 May 410.1093/molbev/msr12121546353Sanbonmatsu-GámezS,
Pérez-RuizM,
CollaoX,
Sánchez-SecoMP,
Morillas-MárquezF, de la
Rosa-FraileM, Toscana virus in Spain.Emerg Infect Dis.
2005;11:1701–710.3201/eid1111.05085116318721ChelbiI,
DerbaliM,
Al-AhmadiZ,
ZaafouriB, El
FahemA,
ZhiouaE. Phenology of
Phlebotomus papatasi (Diptera: Psychodidae) relative to
the seasonal prevalence of zoonotic cutaneous leishmaniasis in central
Tunisia.J Med Entomol.
2007;44:385–810.1603/0022-2585(2007)44[385:POPPDP]2.0.CO;217427714