Emerg Infect DisEIDEmerging Infectious Diseases1080-60401080-6059Centers for Disease Control and Prevention21291611320475410-055110.3201/eid1702.100551DispatchSurveillance for West Nile Virus in Dead Wild Birds, South Korea, 2005–2008Surveillance for WNV in Dead Wild BirdsYehJung-YongKimHyun-JuNahJin-JuLeeHangKimYoung-JunMoonJin-SanChoIn-SooChoiIn-SooSongChang-SeonLeeJoong-BokAuthor affiliations: National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service, Gyeonggi-do, South Korea (J.-Y. Yeh, H-J. Kim, J.-J. Nah, J.-S. Moon, I.-S. Cho);Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea (H. Lee, Y.-J. Kim);Konkuk University, Seoul (I.-S. Choi, C.-S.Song, J.-B. Lee)Address for correspondence: Jung-Yong Yeh, National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service, Anyang 430-824, South Korea; email: yeh02@nvrqs.go.kr22011172299301

To investigate the possibility of West Nile virus (WNV) introduction into South Korea, the National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service has conducted nationwide surveillance of WNV activity in dead wild birds since 2005. Surveillance conducted during 2005–2008 found no evidence of WNV activity.

Keywords: West Nile Virusviruseswild birdszoonosessurveillanceSouth Koreadispatch

Wild birds are considered the principal hosts of West Nile virus (WNV). In the United States, surveillance of birds for WNV is used to quickly detect outbreaks and take action against its spread. The sampling of sick or dead birds can indicate WNV in a region before human and equine cases occur (1). This approach is considered the most effective method for detecting WNV in a specific region. During 1999, mass deaths among wild birds indicated the emergence and rapid spread of WNV in North America.

Although WNV has not yet been detected in South Korea, the perceived threat of its arrival has been highlighted by reports of WNV infection in a dead cinereous vulture (Aegypius monachus) in the Vladivostok region of Russia, which is adjacent to the Korean peninsula (2), and in several samples from cinereous vultures and cattle egrets (Bubulcus ibis) in the Russian Far Eastern Region during 2002–2004 (3). A variety of migratory birds, such as Mandarin ducks (Aix galericulata), cinereous vultures, bean geese (Anser fabalis), and white-fronted geese (Anser albifrons), fly from Russia to South Korea during the winter for the breeding season (46). Furthermore, Saito et al. recently reported that test results on several migrating birds captured in Japan were positive for flavivirus antibodies (7). This finding suggests that the threat of WNV in South Korea is increasing because many migratory birds share flyways over South Korea and Japan (8). Therefore, spread of the virus by migratory birds from WNV-infected areas, such as Russia, into uninfected hosts throughout the Korean peninsula is likely.

The Study

A wide variety of bird species from all regions of South Korea were tested, and particular attention was paid to susceptible species and birds with neurologic signs. Carcasses of wild birds submitted to the Conservation Genome Resource Bank for Korean Wildlife, Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea, were used for this study. The study also included samples from dead wild birds submitted to the Animal Disease Diagnostic Center of the National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service of the Ministry of Food, Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of South Korea.

Investigation focused on the presumed peak period of mosquito vector activity (April–October) and included samples from dead wild birds. A total of 715 wild birds (belonging to 72 species) from all regions of South Korea were found dead and were examined during 2005–2008. All carcasses underwent postmortem examination, during which samples were obtained for diagnosis. In 2005, a total of 51 samples were tested; 167 samples were tested in 2006, 239 in 2007, and 258 in 2008. Taxonomic families of the collected birds and their migratory status are shown in Table A1. Samples from Ae. monachus, A. fabalis, and A. albifrons birds, which are known to migrate from the Russian Eastern Region to South Korea (4,5), were included. Samples of dead wild birds such as Corvidae spp. and raptors (Accipitridae and Strigidae spp.), which have been identified as potential sources of WNV for resident birds (9,10), were also included.

Carcasses were subjected to necropsy, and brains and kidneys were obtained. Organs were homogenized in phosphate-buffered saline (10% suspension) and centrifuged. Ten 50% tissue culture infectious doses of a stock WNV were used as a control for antigen detection. WNV RNA in samples was investigated by reverse transcription–PCR with primers (Table). Information on the RNA extraction and the reverse transcription–PCR used is available in the Technical Appendix.

During 2005–2008, we analyzed 1,309 organ samples (639 brain and 670 kidney) from dead birds for WNV RNA. WNV was not detected in these samples. Diagnostic examination of wild birds as a part of the nationwide surveillance has not detected patterns or clusters of birds with evidence of neurologic disease or viral encephalitides suggestive of WNV infection. Several cases of mass die-offs among wild birds were the result of chemical poisoning (11).

Conclusions

Our surveillance of wild birds conducted during 2005–2008 supports the hypothesis that WNV has not reached South Korea and corroborates findings of previous reports. In a study conducted at the National Institute of Health, Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2,275 pools of mosquitoes were tested for WNV RNA; results for all samples obtained during 2006–2008 were negative (12). The study reported that 27 cerebrospinal fluid samples and 57 serum specimens obtained from patients who were suspected of having Japanese encephalitis and dengue fever were also negative for WNV. In another surveillance study of mosquitos and crows in Japan, a country near South Korea, no WNV RNA was detected. This study included mosquitoes obtained in a park in Tokyo during 2002–2006 and 329 captured or dead crows obtained during1994–2006 (13). In addition, antibodies against WNV antibodies were not detected in 18 crows sampled during 1995–2003. The first human WNV infection in Japan was confirmed in a person who returned from the United States in 2005 (14). However, no indigenous human or equine cases have been reported.

Although our surveillance found no evidence of WNV in South Korea, WNV could be introduced into this country in the near future. Moreover, several species of mosquitoes with the ability to transmit WNV have been identified in South Korea. Turell et al. reported that mosquitoes captured in Paju County, Gyeonggi Province, South Korea, were highly susceptible to WNV infection when they fed on viremic chickens (15).

Introduction of WNV into South Korea would undoubtedly become a major public health problem. An outbreak similar to the one that occurred in New York during 1999 could result in the disease becoming endemic to the country. Continued surveillance of dead wild birds is essential to enable prompt detection of WNV. Additionally, WNV surveillance programs in South Korea should continue to examine cases of viral encephalitis in horses and mass deaths among birds. Temperature increases caused by climate change should also be taken into account, and vigilant monitoring of emerging arboviruses, in addition to WNV, will be required. Finally, increased cooperation between the government and other agencies, such as wildlife conservation organizations and horse-racing authorities, is needed for early detection of WNV disease and development of effective veterinary and public health strategies.

Supplementary MaterialTechnical Appendix

Reverse Transcription PCR Methods.

Suggested citation for this article: Yeh J-Y, Kim H-J, Nah J-J, Lee H, Kim Y-J, Moon J-S, et al. Surveillance for West Nile virus in dead wild birds, South Korea, 2005–2008. Emerg Infect Dis [serial on the Internet]. 2011 Feb [date cited]. http://dx.doi.org/10.3201/eid1702.100551

This study was supported by a grant from the National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service, Republic of Korea.

Migration status (seasonality) and abundance of 715 dead wild birds (72 species) with West Nile virus infection, South Korea, 2005–2008
Family, common nameSpeciesNo. samples*Migration status†
Accipitridae
Cinereous vultureAegypius monachus1W3, RV3
Common buzzardButeo buteo8P3, W3, SV3
Eurasian sparrowhawkAccipiter nisus1P3, RV2
Common kingfisherAlcedo atthis3S2, R(m)5
Black-capped kingfisher
Halcyon pileata
2
S3
Anatidae
Baikal tealAnas formosa6W1, SV3
PintailAnas acuta2P2, W2
White-fronted gooseAnser albifrons6P1, W2, SV2
Common tealAnas crecca7W2, RV1
ParrotLorius domicella1Exotic
Mandarin duckAix galericulata2R(m)3, W3
MallardAnas platyrhynchos60P1, W1, R4
Bean gooseAnser fabalis2P1, W2, SV2
Spot-billed duck
Anas poecilorhyncha
16
P1, W1, R2
Ardeidae
Striated heronButorides striatus3S3
Great egretCasmerodius albus2W3, SV1
Little egretEgretta garzetta8S2, W4
Gray heronArdea cinerea9S3, W3
Great egretEgretta alba4S2, WV1
Intermediate egretEgretta intermedia1S3
Black-crowned night heronNycticorax nycticorax5S3, R4
Buff-backed heron, cattle egret
Bubulcus ibis
10
S2
Caprimulgidae
Gray nightjar
Caprimulgus indicus
5
P3, S3
Ciconiidae
Oriental white stork
Ciconia boyciana
1
W5, SV3
Columbidae
Rufous turtle doveStreptopelia orientalis19R1, P3
Hill pigeonColumba rupestris rupestris39R5
Feral rock pigeon
Columba livia
3
R(m)2
Coraciidae
Broad-billed roller
Eurystomus orientalis
3
P3, S3
Corvidae
Black-billed magpiePica pica96R(m)1
Azure-winged magpieCyanopica cyana1R(m)2
JayGarrulus glandarius6R(m)1
Jungle crow
Corvus macrorhynchos
3
R(m)2
Cuculidae
Oriental cuckooCuculus saturates1S2
Common cuckoo
Cuculus canorus
1
S1
Emberizidae
Rustic bunting
Emberiza rustica
2
P1, W1
Falconidae
Eurasian hobbyFalco subbuteo10S3
Common kestrel
Falco tinnunculus
11
R(m)3, S2
Fringillidae
Eurasian siskinCarduelis spinus1P1, W1, SV3
Gray-capped greenfinch
Carduelis sinica ussuriensis
1
R(m)1, W2
Gaviidae
Red-throated diver
Gavia stellata
1
P3, W3
Hirundinidae
House swallow
Hirundo rustica
1
P1, S1, WV3
Laridae
Black-tailed gullLarus crassirostris2S2, W2
Herring gull
Larus argentatus
1
W2, RV1
Muscicapidae
Blue-and-white flycatcher
Cyanoptila cyanomela
1
P2, S2
Oriolidae
Black-naped oriole
Oriolus chinensis
2
P2, S2
Paradoxornithidae
Vinous-throated parrotbill
Paradoxornis webbiana
1
R(m)1
Paridae
Great tit
Parus major
2
R(m)1
Passeridae
Tree sparrow
Passer montanus
18
P3, W3, R5
Phasianidae
Golden pheasantChrysolophus pictus1Exotic
Ring-necked pheasantPhasianus colchicus39R1
ChickenGallus gallus domesticus1R1
Korean black chicken
Gallus gallus var. domesticus
1
R1
Picidae
Great spotted woodpeckerDendrocopos major1R(m)2
Japanese pigmy woodpeckerDendrocopos kizuki1R1
Green woodpecker
Picus viridus
1
R(m)3
Procellariidae
Streaked shearwater
Calonectris leucomelas
1
S2
Pycnonotidae
Brown-eared bulbul
Hypsipetes amaurotis
11
R(m)1, S3, W3
Rallidae
CootFulica atra1W3, R4
Moorhen
Gallinula chlororpus
1
S4, R5
Scolopacidae
WoodcockScolopax rusticola6P4, W5
Whimbrel
Numenius phaeopus variegatus
1
P3, WV3
Strigidae
Eurasian scops owlOtus scops stictonotus33P3, S3
Brown hawk owlNinox scutulat37P4, S4
Eurasian eagle owlBubo bubo20R(m)4
Tawny owlStrix aluco1R4
Long-eared owlAsio otus2P5, W5
Collared scops owl
Otus lempiji
7
R(m)3, W4
Sturnidae
Gray starling
Sturnus cineraceus
1
W2, R(m)2
Turdidae
Gray-backed thrushTurdus hortulorum1P3, S3
White`s thrush
Zoothera dauma
13
S2, W4
Zosteropidae
Japanese white-eye
Zosterops japonica japonica
1
R(m)3, P4
Unidentified

142

Total715

*Samples were received from natural heritage centers, wildlife rescue organizations, and private veterinary practices.
†Letters are used in a wide range of combinations to suggest a species’ seasonality. R, resident; R(m), resident and partial migrant; P, passage migrant (i.e., spring, autumn, or both); W, winter visitor; S, summer visitor or summer resident. Numbers (1–5) are used to express estimated abundance since 1980: 1, numerous (>100,000 records or individuals); 2, rather common/locally common (10,000–100,000 records or individuals); 3, fairly common (1,000–<10,000 records or individuals); 4, uncommon or rather local (100–<1,000 records or individuals); 5, scarce or very local (recorded annually, with ≥100 records from 1980 to the present time and <100 records estimated to occur annually). For less regularly recorded species, V followed by a number (1–5) indicates all known records (from 1980 to the present time): V1, probable annual (25–99 records or individuals); V2, recorded scarcely annually, or less than annually (10–<25 records or individuals); V3, ≥10 records, n); V4, species last recorded >10 years ago; V5, species added to the Birds Korea Checklist since the past update (starting in October 2007). On occasion, these codes are also used with a prefix (e.g., W, S) to indicate that more abundant species also occur more rarely in a given season (between 1980 and the present time). For example, S3, WV3 indicates that a species that is fairly common in summer has also been recorded <10 times in mid-winter between 1980 and the present time. This manner of measuring migratory status (seasonality) and abundance is followed by The Birds Korea Checklist: 2009 (6).

Oligonucleotide primers used for reverse transcription–PCR of West Nile virus in dead wild birds, South Korea, 2005–2008
PrimerSequence, 5’ →3’Orientation*Genome position†Product size, bp
WN233TTGTGTTGGCTCTCTTGGCGTTCTTS233408
WN640CAGCCGACAGCACTGGACATTCATAAS640408
AmWN1401ACCAACTACTGTGGAGTCS1401445
AmWN1845TTCCATCTTCACTCTACACTAS1845445
AmWN1485GCCTTCATACACACTAAAGS (nested PCR)1485248
AmWN1732CCAATGCTATCACAGACTAS (nested PCR)1732248

*S, sense; AS, antisense.
†Genbank accession no. NC_009942.

Dr Yeh is researcher at the National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service in South Korea. His main research interests are emerging and zoonotic infectious diseases, vector-borne pathogens, and Lawsonia intracellularis.

ReferencesEidson M, Kramer L, Stone W, Hagiwara Y, Schmit K Dead bird surveillance as an early warning system for West Nile virus. Emerg Infect Dis. 2001;7:631510.3201/eid0704.01040511585524Loktev VB West Nile virus, vulture—Russia (VLADIVOSTOK): ProMED-MAIL; 2004 [cited 2010 Dec 21]. http://www.promedmail.orgTernovoĭ VA, Protopopova EV, Surmach SG, Gazetdinov MV, Zolotykh SI, Shestopalov AM, The genotyping of the West Nile virus in birds in the Far Eastern Region of Russia in 2002–2004 [in Russian] Mol Gen Mikrobiol Virusol. 2006;4:30517094656Jin S-D, Baek U-K Research on wintering of Aegypius monachus in Korea. Mun Hwa Jae. 2009;42:6271Kim J, Park J, Yoo B, Rhee D The migration route and monitoring of the migratory birds in Korea. In: Wildlife Biology. Inchon (South Korea): National Institute of Environmental Research; 2002 Report 24:153–64.Moores N, Park J-G, Kim A The birds Korea checklist: 2009 [cited 2010 Dec 21]. http://www.birdskorea.orgSaito M, Osa Y, Asakawa M Antibodies to flaviviruses in wild ducks captured in Hokkaido, Japan: risk assessment of invasive flaviviruses. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis. 2009;9:253810.1089/vbz.2008.011119514809Lee W-S, Gu T-H, Park J-Y A field guide to the birds of Korea. Seoul (South Korea): LG Foundation; 2005Komar N, Langevin S, Hinten S, Nemeth N, Edwards E, Hettler D, Experimental infection of North American birds with the New York 1999 strain of West Nile virus. Emerg Infect Dis. 2003;9:3112212643825Nemeth N, Gould D, Bowen R, Komar N Natural and experimental West Nile virus infection in five raptor species. J Wildl Dis. 2006;42:11316699143Genome Resource Bank for Korean Wildlife 2009 [cited 2010 Dec 22]. http://www.cgrb.org/index_e.htmHan M-G, Lee H-I, Lee C-S, Lee W-G, Jeong Y-E, Cho J-E, Surveillance of West Nile viruses from 2006 to 2008, Korea: no evidence of infection. The Microbiological Society of Korea’s International Symposium. May 28–30, 2009 Jeju Island, Seoul (South Korea): The Microbiological Society of Korea; 2009. p. 237.Tabei Y, Hasegawa M, Iwasaki N, Okazaki T, Yoshida Y, Yano K Surveillance of mosquitoes and crows for West Nile virus in the Tokyo metropolitan area. Jpn J Infect Dis. 2007;60:413618032852Koizumi K, Nakajima Y, Matsuzaki M, Koido N, Ohsone Y, Lim CK, First report of West Nile fever in Japan [in Japanese] Kansenshogaku Zasshi. 2006;80:56716519126Turell MJ, Mores CN, Dohm DJ, Lee WJ, Kim HC, Klein TA Laboratory transmission of Japanese encephalitis, West Nile, and Getah viruses by mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae) collected near Camp Greaves, Gyeonggi Province, Republic of Korea 2003. J Med Entomol. 2006;43:10768110.1603/0022-2585(2006)43[1076:LTOJEW]2.0.CO;217017248