These infections are associated with a variety of clinical syndromes, in part related to specific serotype.
A new reverse transcription–polymerase chain reaction assay was developed for identification of 28 Canadian human parechovirus (HPeV) isolates, including 20 HPeV-1, 3 HPeV-2, and 5 HPeV-3, recovered from 1985 to 2004. All HPeV-1 isolates but 1 were genetically distinct from the Harris reference strain. One HPeV-2 isolate was related to the Williamson strain; the other 2 were related to the Connecticut strain. HPeV-3 isolates clustered together. Seventy-five percent of isolates were recovered during the typical enterovirus season. All patients but 1 were children with a mean age of 14.6 months, 6.3 months, and 0.7 months for HPeV-1, HPeV-2, and HPeV-3 patients, respectively. All HPeV-2– and HPeV-3–infected children were hospitalized with a diagnosis of viremia or sepsis. HPeV-1–infected children had bronchiolitis diagnosed in 50% of the cases, with few cases of pneumonia and enteritis. Two infected patients (1 child with leukemia and a 78-year-old woman) died of septic shock and severe pneumonia, respectively.
Picornaviruses constitute a diverse family of single-stranded positive-sense RNA viruses whose genome is packed into a nonenveloped icosahedral capsid (
Previous studies demonstrated that HPeV-1 (formerly echovirus 22) had a worldwide distribution and was associated with diseases similar to those caused by human enteroviruses (HEVs), i.e., gastroenteritis, respiratory diseases, aseptic meningitis, encephalitis, and neonatal sepsis–like syndromes (
Similar to HEVs, HPeVs infections are commonly identified by virus isolation in cell culture, followed by neutralization typing (
A total of 30 HPeV strains, including the reference strains Harris (HPeV-1, ATCC VR-52), and Williamson (HPeV-2, ATCC VR-53), as well as 28 clinical HPeV isolates were used in this study (
| Virus | HPeV type | % nt/aa identities† | Neutralization assay‡ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Harris | 1 | NA | + |
| Williamson | 2 | NA | + |
| Can4541-85 | 1 | 76.7/89.9 | + |
| Can-5188-85 | 1 | 76.8/89.9 | + |
| Can11750-87 | 1 | 76.8/89.9 | + |
| Can11758-87 | 1 | 76.8/89.9 | + |
| Can29218-90 | 1 | 76.4/89.2 | + |
| Can29192-90 | 1 | 75.0/89.6 | + |
| Can40057-93 | 1 | 76.8/89.6 | + |
| Can41934-93 | 1 | 77.1/89.6 | + |
| Can61165-97 | 1 | 77.0/89.9 | + |
| Can82753-01 | 1 | 76.5/89.2 | + |
| Can81805-01 | 1 | 85.1/97.5 | + |
| Can87376-02 | 1 | 76.4/89.6 | + |
| Can87639-02 | 1 | 76.4/89.6 | + |
| Can88461-02 | 1 | 77.1/89.9 | + |
| Can88770-02 | 1 | 76.3/89.2 | + |
| Can85372-02 | 1 | 76.5/89.2 | + |
| Can84436-02 | 1 | 76.9/89.6 | + |
| Can101909-04 | 1 | 76.6/89.6 | + |
| Can102318-04 | 1 | 76.6/89.6 | + |
| Can100121-04 | 1 | 77.0/89.2 | + |
| Can82047-01 | 2 | 81.1/96.4 | + |
| Can95219-03 | 2 | 67.8/72.5 | – |
| Can95224-03 | 2 | 67.8/72.5 | – |
| Can81235-01 | 3 | 95.3/96.1 | – |
| Can81554-01 | 3 | 95.0/95.7 | – |
| Can82853-01 | 3 | 95.5/96.4 | – |
| Can99190-04 | 3 | 95.0/96.1 | – |
| Can97858-04 | 3 | 95.0/96.4 | – |
*HPeV, human parechovirus; nt, nucleotide; aa, amino acid; NA, not applicable. †% identities were calculated by comparison with Harris (accession no. S45208), Williamson (accession no. AJ005695) and A308/99 (accession no. AB084913) reference strains for HPeV-1, -2 and -3 isolates, respectively. ‡Neutralization assays were performed by using specific HPeV-1 and -2 (formerly echovirus 22 and 23, respectively) antisera (MA Bioproducts, Walkersville, MD, USA).
HPeV genomic RNA was isolated from the supernatant of infected cell cultures with the QIAamp Viral RNA kit (Qiagen, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada). cDNA was prepared by using the HPeVUniv5´ primer selected from the C-terminal region of the capsid VP0 encoding gene: 5´-GCT GAC CTA TGY ATC CCC TAT GT-3´ (nt 1358–1379, GenBank accession no. AJ998818) and the SuperScript II reverse transcriptase (Gibco BRL, Burlington, Ontario, Canada). Viral cDNA was then amplified by PCR by using the
Demographic and clinical informations were retrospectively collected from clinical charts of hospitalized patients for whom a positive culture for HPeV was obtained in our laboratory in the past 20 years. The Mann-Whitney rank sum test was used to compare the mean age of patients infected with HPeV-1 versus HPeV-3; the Fisher exact test was used to compare HPeV-1 versus the 2 other HPeV types regarding the rate of underlying diseases and the nature of initial diagnosis.
Among the different cell lines used, HT-29 was found to be the most suitable for efficient isolation of HPeV-1 and -2. Both grew efficiently in this cell line with an evident CPE noted after a mean incubation time of 3.8 days (range 1–8 days). A presumptive distinction between HPeV- and HEV-induced CPE in this cell line was possible. Parechovirus-infected cells were large, regularly shaped spheres, whereas enterovirus-infected cells were rather small with an irregular shape (
Cytopathic effects (CPEs) observed 3 days after infection of HT-29 cells with an enterovirus or a human parechovirus (HPeV)-1 isolate after 1 passage on this cell line (A); CPE observed 1 day after infection of LLC-MK2 cells with a HPeV-3 isolate after 3 passages on this cell line (B).
All HPeV clinical isolates as well as the 2 HPeV-1 and -2 reference strains were efficiently amplified by our RT-PCR test, generating an amplicon of the expected size (≈1,000 bp). No PCR products were generated from enterovirus (coxsackievirus A4 and coxsackievirus B4) and rhinovirus (n = 2) clinical isolates. Conversely, our HPeV isolates were negative when tested by our HEV RT-PCR assay, which is based on the amplification of the 5´ noncoding region. Sequencing of HPeV PCR products confirmed the presence of the VP3 gene in our HPeV-1 (n = 20), HPeV-2 (n = 3) and HPeV-3 (n = 5) clinical isolates. Sequence analysis showed that HPeV-1 clinical isolates had 75.0% to 85.1% nt and 89.2 to 97.5% amino acid identities with the prototype Harris strain (accession no. S45208) (Table). HPeV-2 isolates had nucleotide and amino acid identities of 67.8% to 81.1% and 72.5% to 96.4%, respectively, with the prototype Williamson strain (accession no. AJ005695). Of note, Can95219-03 and Can95224-03 HPeV-2 isolates had the same sequence and were more related to the Connecticut CT-80-6760 HPeV-2 strain (accession no. AF055846) with which they had nucleotide and amino acid identities of 85.1% and 95.8%, respectively. HPeV-3 isolates had nucleotide and amino acid identities of 95.0% to 95.5% and 95.7% to 96.4%, respectively, with the Japanese A308/99 HPeV-3 isolate (accession no. AB084913).
Phylogenetic analysis confirmed the identities of HPeV isolates. The HPeV-1 isolate Can81805-01 was closely related to the reference Harris strain (lineage II), whereas the remaining 19 isolates from this study, as well as 3 other Japanese HPeV-1 isolates (A1087-99, A942-99, and A10987-00), were found to form a distinct cluster (lineage I) (
Phylogenetic analysis of Canadian human parechovirus (HPeV) isolates and HPeV-1 (Harris, GenBank accession no. S45208), HPeV-2 (Williamson, AJ005695, and Connecticut, AF055846), and HPeV-3 (A308-99, AB084913) reference strains based on the ClustalW alignment of the VP3 amino acid sequences. Japanese HPeV-1 (A1087-99, accession no. AB112485; A942-99, AB112486; and A10987-00, AB112487) and HPeV-3 (A628-99, accession no. AB112484; A317-99, AB112482, and A354-99, AB112483) isolates were also included in the analysis. The tree was constructed by using the neighbor-joining method with the MEGA 2 program. Bootstrap probabilities for 550 replicas are shown at the branch nodes. Only values of 70% to 100% are indicated.
The alignment of the predicted amino acid sequences of the partial VP0–VP3 region of Canadian HPeV-1, -2 and -3 isolates with the reference strains showed differences in the VP0/VP3 cleavage site, which was N/N in Can952219-03 and Can95224-03 (HPeV-2), N/S in Connecticut CT80-6760, T/A in Williamson and Can82047-01 (HPeV-2), N/A in Harris and all Canadian HPeV-1 isolates, and N/G in all HPeV-3 isolates (
Comparison of the predicted VP0-VP3 capsid protein region of Canadian isolates with that of Harris (human parechovirus [HPeV]-1), Williamson and Connecticut (HPeV-2), and A308-99 (HPeV-3) strains. The aligned region contains 284 amino acids. corresponding to residues 244 to 521 in the Harris polyprotein sequence (accession no. S45208). The VP3 N-terminal extension, which is specific to parechoviruses (
Twenty-eight HPeV isolates, recovered in the Quebec City area between 1985 and 2004, were available for this study (Table). This collection included 20 (71.4%) HPeV-1, 3 (10.7%) HPeV-2, and 5 (17.8%) HPeV-3. The viral isolates were recovered predominantly from NPAs (n = 16), but also from throat swab specimens (n = 2), endotracheal secretions (n = 2), stool samples (n = 7), and CSF (n = 1) (
Twenty-seven (96.4%) of the 28 patients were children <4 years (mean 11.1 months, median 7.0 months, range 1 week to 4 years). Mean age was 14.6, 6.3, and 0.7 months for HPeV-1–, HPeV-2–, and HPeV-3–infected children, respectively (p<0.001 for comparison of HPeV-1 vs HPeV-3). The 78-year-old adult excreted HPeV-1 in her endotracheal secretions. The female-to-male ratio was 1.2 (54.2% vs. 45.8%). Seventy-five percent of all HPeV isolates were recovered during the typical enterovirus season, i.e., during summer (28.6%) and fall (46.4%). The epidemiology of the newly described HPeV-3 was similar to that of other HPeVs, with 80% of this viral serotype isolated during the summer-fall period.
Among patients for whom information was available, 33.3% (8/24) had an underlying disease, including 2 children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) (
Among the 24 children with available information, bronchiolitis, pneumonitis, or both, were reported as the final diagnosis in 50.0% of cases, whereas acute otitis media, sinusitis, and conjunctivitis were secondary diagnoses in 37.5%, 8.3%, and 4.2% of cases, respectively (
A few cases are particularly worth noting. As previously mentioned, patient 6 was the only child who died after HPeV infection in our cohort. At the time of his HPeV-1 infection, the 4-year-old boy was receiving consolidation chemotherapy for ALL. He was admitted with high fever (40°C), dry cough, and abdominal pain. Over a course of 4 to 5 days, the following conditions developed: bilateral pneumonitis, which required mechanical ventilation, hepatitis, and septic shock complicated by renal insufficiency, for which dialysis was necessary. He died of multiorgan failure while receiving treatment with amphotericin B, acyclovir, meropenem, and vancomycin; no autopsy was performed. Apart from isolation of HPeV-1 from a throat swab, no other microorganisms (bacteria, fungi, and viruses) were recovered from blood, urine, and endotracheal secretions. Also of interest are the clinical signs and symptoms of 1-month-old twins infected by HPeV-2, who were admitted to the hospital on the same day with high fever and irritability. In 1 case (patient 20), HPeV-2 was recovered from CSF and NPA samples, whereas the virus was only isolated in NPA from the other twin (patient 21). The viruses from the 2 children had identical VP3 gene sequences. Both infants received broad-spectrum antimicrobial drugs (ampicillin plus cefotaxime) for 3 days for suspected sepsis, and both had rapid clinical improvement. Patient 26 was the only adult infected with HPeV (type 1) in our study. This 78-year-old woman was admitted to the hospital for several fractures caused by a car accident. One month after admission, bilateral pneumonia developed. She eventually died of respiratory failure 43 days after admission. An endotracheal culture was positive for HPeV-1 12 days before her death; however, results of bacterial cultures were unavailable because part of her clinical chart was destroyed a few years after her death in 1987. No autopsy report was available.
In this study, we retrospectively characterized 28 clinical HPeV isolates recovered during the last 2 decades in Québec, Canada, using a new RT-PCR assay. To date, our study is the only one that analyzed virologic and clinical data from the 3 HPeV serotypes. The study clearly demonstrated the importance of these pathogens and highlighted some clinical differences between infection caused by the 3 serotypes.
Virus isolation, followed by neutralization assays, a procedure that has been generally used for identification of HEVs and HPeVs, is laborious, time-consuming, and may lack sensitivity. Because of substantial sequence differences between HEVs and HPeVs, even within the conserved 5´ noncoding region (
By sequencing the PCR product, we could not only differentiate the 3 HPeV types but also make an intratypic discrimination. Our phylogenetic analysis demonstrated the existence of 2 clusters for HPeV-1 strains. The first contained a Can81805-01 isolate and was closely related to the Harris reference strain; the second cluster included the remaining 19 Canadian isolates as well as recent Japanese HPeV-1 isolates (
The HPeV-1 serotype was shown to be the most frequent, representing >70% of our HPeV isolates. The HPeV-2 serotype was the less frequent, with only 3 cases reported. A very limited number of HPeV-2 infections has also been reported by a Swedish group (
HPeVs have been generally isolated from stool and NPA (
With the exception of one 78-year-old case-patient, all HPeV infections described in this retrospective study were in children <4 years, which confirms the particular importance of these pathogens in the pediatric population (
Our study showed that HPeVs seem to share with HEVs the same epidemiologic pattern, i.e., a peak during the summer-fall months. In addition, the epidemiology of HPeV-3 appears to be similar to that of the 2 other HPeV types in our study, whereas it was slightly different in the Dutch study (
Most HPeV cases reported here were associated with hospitalizations (mean hospital stay 3.7 days). No differences were found between the 3 HPeV types in this aspect. Nevertheless, only HPeV-1 infections led to severe diseases, i.e., 3 patients were transferred to an intensive care unit. Our study also showed the high rate of underlying diseases in our infected patients, which were particularly frequent (≈50%) in HPeV-1 cases. Also, substantial differences in clinical signs and symptoms were seen between the HPeV types. All 7 patients with HPeV-2 and -3 infections were admitted with a diagnosis of sepsislike illness in contrast to none of the 20 HPeV-1 patients (p = 0.001). Sepsislike illness seems to be a notable clinical feature of HPeV-3 infection, as first reported by us (
HPeV-1 has been reported to cause mainly gastrointestinal and respiratory diseases and fewer CNS symptoms (
In conclusion, this study confirms that all 3 HPeVs are pathogens that are particularly important in the pediatric setting, that is, responsible for hospitalizations and some severe infections. HPeV infections could encompass a variety of clinical syndromes with respiratory, gastrointestinal, cerebral, and sepsislike diseases. Molecular assays now allow for their specific detection and should contribute to increased knowledge regarding their incidence, epidemiologic features, and clinical manifestations.
We are grateful to Suzanne Tessier and Marthe Gauthier for their valuable technical assistance.
| Patient/viral isolate | Sex | Age (mo) | Sample date | Sample type | HPeV type | Underlying disease | Hospital/ICU stay (d) | Diagnosis | Death | Copathogen |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1/Can29218-90 | F | 48 | Dec 3, 1990 | NPA | 1 | Di George syndrome | 3/– | Bilateral pneumonia, left AOM | No | None |
| 2/Can40057-93 | M | 14 | Mar 22, 1993 | NPA | 1 | None | 4/– | Pansinusitis, bilateral AOM | No | None |
| 3/Can11750-87 | M | 7 | May 8, 1987 | Throat | 1 | Vater syndrome | 129/– | Bronchiolitis† | No | HRSV |
| 4/Can99190-04 | F | 1 | Jun 27, 2004 | NPA | 3 | None | 3/– | Viremia/sepsis, left conjunctivitis | No | None |
| 5/Can101909-04 | M | 15 | Dec 3, 2004 | NPA | 1 | Febrile convulsions | 1/– | Febrile convulsions, left AOM | No | None |
| 6/Can85372-02 | M | 48 | Apr 1, 2002 | Throat | 1 | ALL on chemotherapy | 5/4 | Bilateral pneumonia, septic shock | Yes | None |
| 7/Can61165-97 | F | 7 | Aug 20, 1997 | Stool (+ urine) | 1 | Heart hypoplasia | 13/– | Enteritis | No | None |
| 8/Can102318-04 | F | 12 | Dec 18, 2004 | NPA | 1 | None | 2/– | Right pneumonia, right AOM | No | None |
| 9/Can97858-04 | M | 0.5 | Apr 2, 2004 | NPA | 3 | None | 7/– | Viremia/sepsis | No | None |
| 10/Can87639-02 | M | 18 | Sep 13, 2002 | NPA | 1 | None | 2/– | Bronchiolitis, left AOM | No | HRSV |
| 11/Can88770-02 | M | 9 | Nov 27, 2002 | NPA | 1 | None | 2/– | Bronchiolitis, bilateral AOM | No | None |
| 12/Can81805-01 | F | 18 | Oct 15, 2001 | Stool | 1 | ALL (de novo) | 25/– | Enteritis,† bronchospasm† | No | None |
| 13/Can84436-02 | M | 2 | Feb 13, 2002 | NPA | 1 | None | 1/– | Bronchiolitis | No | HRSV |
| 14/Can88461-02 | F | 5 | Nov 8, 2002 | NPA | 1 | Fallot tetralogy | 5/– | Bronchiolitis | No | HPIV-3 |
| 15/Can87376-02 | F | 6 | Aug 26, 2002 | NPA | 1 | None | 2/– | Bronchiolitis, bilateral AOM | No | None |
| 16/Can81235-01 | M | 1 | Sep 6, 2001 | NPA | 3 | None | 5/– | Viremia/sepsis | No | None |
| 17/Can81554-01 | F | 0.75 | Sep 27, 2001 | NPA | 3 | None | 5/– | Viremia/sepsis, left conjunctivitis | No | Adenovirus |
| 18/Can82753-01 | F | 11 | Dec 11, 2001 | NPA | 1 | None | 3/– | Bronchiolitis, bilateral AOM | No | None |
| 19/Can82853-01 | F | 0.25 | Dec 17, 2001 | NPA | 3 | None | 5/– | Viremia/sepsis, bilateral AOM | No | None |
| 20‡/Can95224-03 | M | 1 | Oct 30, 2003 | CSF (+NPA) | 2 | None | 3/– | Viremia | No | None |
| 21‡/Can95219-03 | F | 1 | Oct 30, 2003 | NPA | 2 | None | 3/– | Viremia | No | None |
| 22/Can29192-90 | F | 16 | Nov 30, 1990 | Stool | 1 | None | 3/– | Enteritis | No | None |
| 23/Can100121-04 | F | 21 | Aug 9, 2004 | Stool | 1 | Asthma | 0/– | Enteritis | No | None |
| 24/Can82047-01 | ND | 17 | Oct 30, 2001 | Stool | 2 | ND | ND/ND | ND | ND | ND |
| 25/Can41934-93 | M | 4 | Jul 28, 1993 | Tracheal | 1 | None | ND/yes (duration?) | Bilateral pneumonia, respiratory failure | ND | None |
| 26/Can11758-87 | F | 78 years | Mar 25, 1987 | Tracheal | 1 | ND | 43/Yes (duration?) | Bilateral pneumonia,† respiratory failure† | Yes | ND |
| 27/Can5188-85 | ND | 11 | Jul 22, 1985 | Stool | 1 | ND | ND/ND | ND | ND | ND |
| 28/Can4541-85 | ND | 6 | Feb 4, 1985 | Stool | 1 | ND | ND/ND | ND | ND | ND |
*HPeV, human parechovirus; ICU, intensive care unit; NPA, nasopharyngeal aspirate; AOM, acute otitis media; HRSV, human respiratory syncytial virus; ALL, acute lymphoblastic leukemia; HPIV, human parainfluenza virus; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; ND, not determined. †Nosocomial acquisition. ‡Twins.
Dr Abed is a project leader at the Research Center in Infectious Diseases of Laval University. His research interests include influenza and emerging respiratory viruses.
Dr Boivin holds a Canada Research Chair on Emerging Viruses and Antiviral Resistance at Laval University. His specific research interests include respiratory viruses and herpesviruses.