Using oral swab samples to detect West Nile virus in dead birds, we compared the Rapid Analyte Measurement Platform (RAMP) assay with VecTest and real-time reverse-transcriptase–polymerase chain reaction. The sensitivities of RAMP and VecTest for testing corvid species were 91.0% and 82.1%, respectively.
Since the discovery of West Nile virus (WNV) in New York in 1999, an integral part of monitoring has been testing dead bird tissue by using real-time and standard reverse-transcriptase–polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) (
In this study we evaluated another alternative for WNV detection, the Rapid Analyte Measurement Platform (RAMP, Response Biomedical Corp, Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada). Limited studies conducted at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Canadian National Microbiology Laboratory indicated that the RAMP WNV test, with detection limits in mosquitoes as low as 3.17 log10 PFU/mL, was more sensitive than VecTest (
This study compared WNV results from the RAMP and VecTest on oral swab samples from dead birds, with RT-PCR on brain tissue as the standard. Brain swab samples were also tested as an alternate antigen source in the RAMP and VecTest.
Birds included in this study were received from mid-May to late November 2004 and from mid-February through May 2005 from counties in New York State. Oral swab samples for the RAMP and VecTest were collected with 2 sterile, polyester fiber-tipped plastic applicators held together and moved around the oral cavity and proximal esophagus. One swab sample was twirled in 1.0 mL of VecTest buffer solution in a 5-mL plastic tube. The second swab sample was either twirled in 1.0 mL of RAMP buffer solution in a separate 5-mL plastic tube or placed in an empty 5-mL plastic tube, capped, and frozen at –20°C for later testing. RAMP tests were run the same day on fresh material or later on frozen samples. Before being tested, all frozen samples were thawed at room temperature; swabs not previously mixed in solution and swabs from thawed carcasses were then mixed in RAMP buffer solution. Samples were taken from the brains of a subset of corvid species by swabbing cerebral parenchyma and processing as for oral samples. The RAMP and VecTest were run according to manufacturers' directions in a class II biosafety cabinet at the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation's Wildlife Pathology Unit. RAMP test values >50, calculated by the RAMP reader, were recorded as positive. Differences in test performance were assessed by chi-square analysis. Data are expressed as a percentage in text and tables only when n is >10.
Brain samples for RT-PCR were taken at necropsy and frozen at –20°C. Brain tissue was analyzed at the Arbovirus Laboratory, Wadsworth Center, New York State Department of Health, as described previously (
In this study, oral samples from 679 birds were tested; 193 (28.4%) were WNV-positive by RT-PCR. RAMP sensitivity was 80.8%, compared to 71.0% for VecTest (
| Species (presented in taxonomic order) | N† | No. positive (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| RAMP | VecTest | ||
| Pelicaniformes | |||
| Double Crested Cormorant ( | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Falconiformes | |||
| Cooper's Hawk ( | 4 | 0 | 0 |
| Red-tailed Hawk ( | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| American Kestrel ( | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| Charadriiformes | |||
| Ring-billed Gull ( | 1 | 1 | 0 |
| Strigiformes | |||
| Great Horned Owl ( | 3 | 1 | 0 |
| Passeriformes | |||
| Eastern Kingbird ( | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Red-eyed Vireo ( | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Blue Jay ( | 27 | 24 (88.9) | 19 (70.4) |
| American Crow ( | 128 | 117 (91.4) | 108 (84.4) |
| Fish Crow ( | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| American Robin ( | 7 | 1 | 1 |
| Gray Catbird ( | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Northern Mockingbird ( | 2 | 1 | 1 |
| Cedar Waxwing ( | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| Northern Cardinal ( | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Common Grackle ( | 3 | 3 | 2 |
| House Finch ( | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| House Sparrow ( | 6 | 5 | 3 |
| Total all species | 193 | 156 (80.8) | 137 (71.0) |
*RAMP, Rapid Analyte Measurement Platform; RT-PCR, reverse transcription–polymerase chain reaction. †No. of birds real-time RT-PCR–positive.
RAMP confirmed more Common Grackles (
To determine if RAMP results were affected by freezing the sample, samples from 13 corvids (10 positive, 3 negative) were retested by using swabs taken from frozen carcasses. Six initially were tested with fresh swabs and 7 with frozen swabs; all retests yielded results similar to initial results. The same results for fresh versus frozen samples were obtained with VecTest (
VecTest specificity with oral swabs was excellent in correctly identifying all 486 RT-PCR–negative birds, returning no false-positive results (
| Species (presented in taxonomic order) | N† | No. negative (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| RAMP | VecTest | ||
| Galliformes | |||
| Ruffed Grouse ( | 12 | 12 | 12 |
| Columbiformes | |||
| Mourning Dove ( | 24 | 24 | 24 |
| Rock Dove ( | 12 | 12 | 12 |
| Passeriformes | |||
| Blue Jay ( | 22 | 20 (90.9) | 22 |
| American Crow ( | 198 | 195 (98.5) | 198 |
| Fish Crow ( | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| American Robin ( | 22 | 20 (90.9) | 22 |
| Gray Catbird ( | 14 | 13 (92.9) | 14 |
| European Starling ( | 11 | 11 | 11 |
| Brown-headed Cowbird ( | 10 | 10 | 10 |
| Common Grackle ( | 19 | 19 | 19 |
| House Sparrow ( | 22 | 22 | 22 |
| Other species‡ | 118 | 118 | 118 |
| Total all species | 486 | 478 (98.4) | 486 |
*RAMP, Rapid Analyte Measurement Platform; RT-PCR, reverse transcription–polymerase chain reaction. †No. real-time RT-PCR–negative birds. ‡52 species, representing 14 orders.
Brain swab samples from 39 corvids were tested; 27 (69.2%) were RT-PCR–positive. Both RAMP and VecTest performed well, with sensitivities of 92.6% and 88.9%, respectively, and no false-positive results.
Although RAMP was more sensitive than VecTest, both appear adequate for WNV surveillance in dead corvids. RAMP also performed well with oral swabs from Common Grackles and House Sparrows, although sample sizes were small. These findings are similar to previous results for VecTest, which also tested well with House Finches (
In the previous New York study, VecTests successfully tested brain, kidney, blood, feather pulp, and cloacal samples from corvids and House Sparrows (
In this study, VecTest produced no false-positive results. Although its specificity was high, RAMP produced 8 false-positive results (range 50.9–147.6). Four of these were near the >50 positive indicator level and may have been due to other sources of fluorescence. The remaining 4 false-positives (3 American Crows and 1 Blue Jay), with scores from 74.4 to 147.6, came from birds with oral cavities compromised by blood or fly eggs, which may have biased results.
VecTest results are easily distinguished when a true WNV-positive reaction occurs, but the reddish-purple line may appear faint or thin in other cases and may be subject to interpretation (
The RAMP system requires an initial purchase of an electronic reader (≈US $3,500), and materials cost $13–$15 per test; VecTest costs $8 per test. If large numbers of specimens are tested, the cost of the RAMP reader per test is minimal. The RAMP test requires a minimum of 1.5 h to run because of the required cartridge drying time; VecTest takes 15–30 min to run after the test strip is placed in the sample solution.
In conclusion, both RAMP and VecTest are useful alternatives to RT-PCR for WNV surveillance in dead corvids and some passerine species when immediate turn-around of large numbers of specimens is valuable. Testing with RAMP is advantageous because of its increased sensitivity; however, follow-up testing with RT-PCR is recommended for low RAMP-positive results near the positive indicator level. Using both tests in a system in which initial testing is conducted with VecTest may also be useful; RAMP could be reserved for high-priority cases in which VecTest results are negative. RT-PCR should still be used to confirm initial viral activity in a new period and area and for research requiring more definitive results.
We thank Kevin Hynes, Joe Okoniewski, and Darci Dougherty for their technical assistance; Dave Galinski for bird necropsy, swab and tissue collection, performance of RAMP, and VecTest; Susan Jones and Mary Franke for real-time RT-PCR assays; county health departments, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Yoichiro Hagiwara, Richard Chipman, Richard A. Watt and other animal control officers, wildlife rehabilitators, and the concerned public for coordinating and participating in dead bird reporting and submission.
The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and the New York State Department of Health jointly supported this research. Work on this study was partially supported by federal funds from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention under cooperative agreement numbers U50/CCU223671 and U90/CCU216988.
Dr Stone has been the wildlife pathologist for the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation for >36 years. He also is an adjunct professor at the State University of New York College at Cobleskill and the College of St. Rose. Dr Stone's main research interests are in infectious and parasitic diseases, toxicology, and forensic pathology of wildlife.